|
Post by jsteiger on Aug 8, 2015 11:59:12 GMT -6
Yes exactly that was my goal but I didn't feel comfortable without being able to test them plus the lack of a schemo.
|
|
|
Post by mulmany on Aug 8, 2015 12:33:41 GMT -6
Yes exactly that was my goal but I didn't feel comfortable without being able to test them plus the lack of a schemo. Jeff, you did not want to call them up and ask for a copy? :-)
|
|
|
Post by Guitar on Aug 8, 2015 14:18:56 GMT -6
Oh man you should have posted these clips as a blind test so we all could have guessed at it. It's just my favorite thing when people guess one way, then the answers are revealed, and people immediately switch to their preferred position based on knowing. That makes me laugh so much every time.
Thanks for posting though, there are very clear differences before and after the mod. To my ear the mod does sound more "vintage" I guess that was exactly the goal. Sounds really good.
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Aug 8, 2015 14:52:24 GMT -6
I might have picked the un-modded as the modded because I would have heard the slightly bigger low end and thought - oh it's bigger, that's it. I'm pretty sure I hear depth and separation differences - the modded having better of the two...but it's pretty subtle. But like it's been said, this is just running through 2 channels. This is a terrible analogy, but when using VCC, you can't hear a difference until you put it on every channel. The difference is absolutely there, but you couldn't hear much of a difference on a single channel more than likely.
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 16:09:04 GMT -6
Thanks for all the feedback guys. I thought about a blind A/B but sometimes those descend in to chaos. I thought I'd rather avoid that. For me the differences are subtle but huge at the same time. As a mixer I'm looking for 100 ways to make something 1% better. This mod, to my ears, with what I want sonically, is more than a 1% change. My heart swelled with love for Jeff when I heard the difference!!! I would easily go through the time, $ and effort for this much improvement every single day!
What I heard immediately is increased clarity and presence in the guitars in the chorus, a more controlled bottom (which to me is not "less" bottom end but more focused bottom end. A definite improvement and one of the worst parts of the stock 1608...sloppy bottom), less congestion in the 2k-4k area, smoother transient behavior, deeper front to back detail, and to my ears it's a wider soundstage. The un-modded mix was really hashy and distorted at the extremes of the stereo field. The modded one is relaxed and clear. I felt like the hashy mess of the un-modded mix gave the impression of width but it was an unuseable width...a false width. When I really focus on the guitar stabs I hear them sitting just beyond the almost hidden guitars of the un-modded mix. In headphones it's a BIG difference. At my mix position it was IMMEDIATELY hearable and it was one of the biggest battles of the mix (it's not a very well tracked production). The center of the modded mix feels relaxed but more clear as well. The sides wrap around it in an arc but there's clarity all the way from left to right...the whole field. Not so on the unmodded mix. The bigger thrill for me is the idea of modding the rest of the console (channels, ACA, 2bus, output) and having the cumulative pleasant effect of all of these improvements working in an integrated system. I did record some vocals and handclaps last night on another track, which I'm mixing down to my 440b on some NOS 1/4" 456. I'm happy to post those files if there's any interest. But the point is that my system is getting closer to my ideal sonic signature as I use the whole thing in concert. When I bought the console I really thought I would be getting an API like the ones I've worked on at Sound Factory, Sunset Sound and my buddy Dave Kalish's restored 1604. Nope. That is not what I got. The console sounds fine but it doesn't sound like those consoles. The difference IS small but it's that last 2% that MAKES it different. This change, to me, is MASSIVE. My bad for not doing the research but I'm busy and I'm fairly uneducated about circuit design and component selection. I'm learning more all the time and it's totally fun and exciting. My plan now (it's a long term one) is to build a couple of Jeff's FET comps and if I like em to fill the 8 aux 500 slots with them and as my solder chops improve to fill the console with Love Child eqs. I find that I do most of my surgical eq ITB anyway so I'm gonna dump the 500 stuff I already have and get more Litz and red dots in this console! If anybody is looking for 500 eqs I've got 10 I'm ready to let go. Pm me. I'm a busy guy and the studio always has more than 1 project going so it's tough for me to do any clinical testing but I'm happy to post stuff as I do it. Just ask for what you wanna hear and I'll post it as I can.
Thanks again guys for the feedback!!!
BTW Jeff, when will Litz X-formers be back in stock? I wanna keep the ball rolling. I REALLY wanna do the ACA groups and the 2 bus. Then stuff is going through delicious LAYERS of this sonic cream puff.
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 16:16:12 GMT -6
I might have picked the un-modded as the modded because I would have heard the slightly bigger low end and thought - oh it's bigger, that's it. I'm pretty sure I hear depth and separation differences - the modded having better of the two...but it's pretty subtle. But like it's been said, this is just running through 2 channels. This is a terrible analogy, but when using VCC, you can't hear a difference until you put it on every channel. The difference is absolutely there, but you couldn't hear much of a difference on a single channel more than likely. You know, JK, I kinda feel the same way but that big bottom has been problematic for me. It's so un-focused and sloppy. With Jeff's mods I feel like I could (and I will when I finish the mix) get MORE bottom in the track but it'll be focused and controlled...it'll hit harder. That BIG bottom on the 1608 has always bugged me and the mess around 2.5k has always forced me to exaggerate it because I'm compensating for the harsh mids. I'm so glad those days are almost over! And yes!!! When I can pile a giant stack of Litz and red dots on a track...then it will behave! My tracks are gonna get a little discipline!!!
|
|
|
Post by jeromemason on Aug 8, 2015 17:00:25 GMT -6
I remember when I first switched to summing through the transformers in my summing mixers, I lost that "big bottom" and I was kind of concerned, but after listening I couldn't help but love how controlled the low-end was, and once I had the gain staging right I was able to get plenty of low-end and it be controlled and tight, with a little warm goodness that iron was imparting. I can hear that in those modded channels, I think I even mentioned it while I was commenting and listening above, the bass seemed to jump around a bit to my taste, yeah it had a little more sub content but those modded channels tamed it and smoothed it right out. There's a fella that mixes in the top 100, only mixes in the box, I hear the same thing in his mixes, they're good mixes but things are just not controlled down there, that's how I can always tell the difference between ITB and a console is listening to how the low-end is packaged. jsteiger could anything be done to noah shain's mixbus? Sorry Noah, I know speaking this way reduces decimals in the bank account but I'm interested now.
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Aug 8, 2015 17:11:33 GMT -6
I might have picked the un-modded as the modded because I would have heard the slightly bigger low end and thought - oh it's bigger, that's it. I'm pretty sure I hear depth and separation differences - the modded having better of the two...but it's pretty subtle. But like it's been said, this is just running through 2 channels. This is a terrible analogy, but when using VCC, you can't hear a difference until you put it on every channel. The difference is absolutely there, but you couldn't hear much of a difference on a single channel more than likely. You know, JK, I kinda feel the same way but that big bottom has been problematic for me. It's so un-focused and sloppy. With Jeff's mods I feel like I could (and I will when I finish the mix) get MORE bottom in the track but it'll be focused and controlled...it'll hit harder. That BIG bottom on the 1608 has always bugged me and the mess around 2.5k has always forced me to exaggerate it because I'm compensating for the harsh mids. I'm so glad those days are almost over! And yes!!! When I can pile a giant stack of Litz and red dots on a track...then it will behave! My tracks are gonna get a little discipline!!! I totally get what you're saying. I felt the same way comparing the bottom on the Svartbox and other pieces. It was just the big sloppy rumble of the bottom that was getting my attention. When it was tight and defined, it almost seemed less. I just bought the Litz VP28 and man, it's even better than I remember the vp28 being. The mids are super smooth. I could just be making that up, but it seems like it's an improvement.
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 17:27:55 GMT -6
theres transformers, capacitors, op-amps, resistors in the 2 bus! Jeff mentioned, in the most casual way, that we might look there as well. I already have Firlotte op-amps in there but I'm gonna get some red dots for it asap.
FWIW this mod, while greatly affecting the bottom, really shines to me on the upper half of the mix. The upper mid and high freq stuff just became much less grainy and hashy to my ears. Not less high but less congested. There's this magic to the high end of well made albums...a smoothness and presence that is pleasant to listen to but doesn't lack "brightness". It's been so hard for me to get. I felt like I got some here. So many people on line (even some well respected tech types) will say something like, "if you want that old sound just low-pass...that old equipment had terrible specs..." You know? Things along those lines. Well I never felt like that was right or true. I think there's probably a solid, scientific reason for it and that it's probably connected to manufacture and component choice...the sound of well designed integrated systems. This mod feels like a step in the right direction in that regard. I'm gonna keep at it. 1% steps to eargasm!
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Aug 8, 2015 17:35:34 GMT -6
I think it's probably the transformers taming the transients and then the roll off of tape...I have to say those Firlotte FC600's or whatever they're called seemed very sharp and "hi-fi" to me. Throw some of those red dots on there!
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 17:42:08 GMT -6
Correct me if I am wrong noah shain, but you were running into the 'line input" for test captures? I would imagine there will be a much more noticeable difference once the mic input trafo's come into play. Track something for us! That's true, line in. I did a vocal and handclaps last night but didn't get to a/b against un-modded. You wanna hear that?
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 17:45:21 GMT -6
I think it's probably the transformers taming the transients and then the roll off of tape...I have to say those Firlotte FC600's or whatever they're called seemed very sharp and "hi-fi" to me. Throw some of those red dots on there! I'm now a believer. I'm gonna do it ASAP. Need Litz stock...JS! I pulled the ACA board and there they are...8 trafos and 8 op amps. I'm gonna see if JS won't coach me on what else we should swap out. I'm hooked. I had more fun mixing last night than I have in months. The 440b might have had something to do with it too;)
|
|
|
Post by jeromemason on Aug 8, 2015 17:54:16 GMT -6
The 440b might have had something to do with it too;) I'm not familiar with that pill imprint.... gonna have to check that one out
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 17:57:57 GMT -6
The 440b might have had something to do with it too;) I'm not familiar with that pill imprint.... gonna have to check that one out It's just like MDMA but with more springs and pulleys!
|
|
|
Post by odyssey76 on Aug 8, 2015 18:40:22 GMT -6
noah shain - just sell that hunk of junk, take the cash and have JS build you a Noah Shain custom console from scratch. The "NS1608 Signature" by CAPN. Got a nice ring to it........
|
|
|
Post by Guitar on Aug 8, 2015 19:29:45 GMT -6
Nice... that would be a pretty serious hunk of equipment with even more CAPI mods, probably drool worthy, haha. That mix sounded really good. This topic is very exciting to me, keep up the good work.
|
|
|
Post by jsteiger on Aug 8, 2015 20:21:35 GMT -6
I think it's probably the transformers taming the transients and then the roll off of tape...I have to say those Firlotte FC600's or whatever they're called seemed very sharp and "hi-fi" to me. Throw some of those red dots on there! Need Litz stock...JS! I pulled the ACA board and there they are...8 trafos and 8 op amps. I'm gonna hit API for schematics and see if JS won't coach me on what else we should swap out. noah shain I just got another batch of Litz 2623-1's in yesterday so I have plenty right now! I would be happy to look into the ACA's and booster amps. Sounds like fun. I wish I was physically closer. Did you dbl check the mic inputs on those channels yet?
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Aug 8, 2015 20:31:31 GMT -6
noah shain - just sell that hunk of junk, take the cash and have JS build you a Noah Shain custom console from scratch. The "NS1608 Signature" by CAPN. Got a nice ring to it........ Now THIS could be the RGO Speedwagon.
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 20:43:32 GMT -6
Nice... that would be a pretty serious hunk of equipment with even more CAPI mods, probably drool worthy, haha. That mix sounded really good. This topic is very exciting to me, keep up the good work. That hunk of junk is the single best sounding piece of gear I've ever heard!!!!! And it's only worth like 1000 bucks tops
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 20:45:12 GMT -6
Need Litz stock...JS! I pulled the ACA board and there they are...8 trafos and 8 op amps. I'm gonna hit API for schematics and see if JS won't coach me on what else we should swap out. noah shain I just got another batch of Litz 2623-1's in yesterday so I have plenty right now! I would be happy to look into the ACA's and booster amps. Sounds like fun. I wish I was physically closer. Did you dbl check the mic inputs on those channels yet? I sent you an email about it Jeff. I DID record with the channels. I was in a proper session though so I couldn't a/b. Sounded amazing. I'll post a file here later tonight!
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 16,107
Member is Online
|
Post by ericn on Aug 8, 2015 20:45:21 GMT -6
noah shain - just sell that hunk of junk, take the cash and have JS build you a Noah Shain custom console from scratch. The "NS1608 Signature" by CAPN. Got a nice ring to it........ Now THIS could be the RGO Speedwagon. I have a dream!
|
|
|
Post by jsteiger on Aug 8, 2015 21:06:54 GMT -6
noah shain I just got another batch of Litz 2623-1's in yesterday so I have plenty right now! I would be happy to look into the ACA's and booster amps. Sounds like fun. I wish I was physically closer. Did you dbl check the mic inputs on those channels yet? I sent you an email about it Jeff. I DID record with the channels. I was in a proper session though so I couldn't a/b. Sounded amazing. I'll post a file here later tonight! Oh sorry. I've been out all day and haven't been able to keep up with my emails
|
|
|
Post by noah shain on Aug 8, 2015 21:47:47 GMT -6
I sent you an email about it Jeff. I DID record with the channels. I was in a proper session though so I couldn't a/b. Sounded amazing. I'll post a file here later tonight! Oh sorry. I've been out all day and haven't been able to keep up with my emails All good Jeff!! I'm so stoked on this.
|
|
|
Post by jeromemason on Aug 9, 2015 1:21:18 GMT -6
Oh sorry. I've been out all day and haven't been able to keep up with my emails All good Jeff!! I'm so stoked on this. I totally think you should build 16 u-pads and use that to mix with. Passing through that 2622 has an amazing sound, you've heard it while recording... but mixing through that plus both output trannies, now that is when things will start getting fan bloody tastic. Seriously though, that input transformer coupled both the output and fader transformer is like pure heaven, each one lends it's own sonics to form a beautiful sound. It's why there still has nothing been created that I've heard that can touch the VP28's on my mixbus, nothing. Those u-pads are easy to make Noah, Switchcraft sells a barrel XLRF-XLRM that has the room to solder in the resistors, and it's very simple. All you need is Jeff to tell you the optimal impedance for the 2622 and what resistors you'll need. You could even test slightly different loads until you found which is perfect. In that case I'd imagine something extremely high tolerance. What would be even cooler is if a little rocker switch was on this so you could go line to mic w/o having to pull the barrel out. I bet someone makes something like that out there. Going into your mixbus, there's all type of possibilities. That's where you could make the console just sound FAT and ballsy as hell.
|
|
|
Post by odyssey76 on Aug 9, 2015 4:58:06 GMT -6
Nice... that would be a pretty serious hunk of equipment with even more CAPI mods, probably drool worthy, haha. That mix sounded really good. This topic is very exciting to me, keep up the good work. That hunk of junk is the single best sounding piece of gear I've ever heard!!!!! And it's only worth like 1000 bucks tops LOL, I was just being facetious, but I'd love to hear/own (in my wildest dreams) something like this built by Jeff! BTW - this thread is incredibly exciting! Can't wait to hear more!!
|
|