|
Post by M57 on Sept 9, 2024 11:54:11 GMT -6
Retired now but here's my resume: We sang in the car everywhere we went when I was a kid. I sang as a soloist in church starting in 6th grade, sang in school, sang in college, took voice lessons in college, and sang thousands of gigs professionally since, both in GB bands and in vocal ensembles ..in a bunch of genres. A good amount of my experience is with a cappella ensembles where I was a soloist/section leader, ranging from small and doo-wap/rockapella style to mid-sized classical choral ensembles with 8-24 members. All small enough that individual voices make impactful contributions to the sound, which is a nice way of saying one rotten singer can ruin the sound.
I have one recommendation: If you can, sing with people who are better than you. My early vocal lessons were all fine and good, but there's nothing like getting out there and seeing and hearing good technique modeled up close and personal. When you're 'singing along' with a better singer, the bar is instantly raised. You learn to match and/or complement their power, tone, vowels, consonants, breathing, intonation, phrasing, and any other aspect of good musicianship you can think of. The good news is in most cases, those musicians want you to get better, and they're more than happy to share their tricks, tips, and insights.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 9, 2024 12:10:58 GMT -6
Great points! BTW IMHO if Tamplin during the Webinar... Had a few featured Strong Pop singers, it would have been a further enhancement. Overall viewing it was worthwhile nonetheless. Thought provoking. I do feel that most of the singers called on, were forcing their voices a bit. Too much throat/not enough Support etc. A useful Supplement is to also "Sing Along" with Records, where the Lead Singer has a similar Voice Type. I'm aware-supposedly-Corelli was mostly self taught. From records!! Chris P.S. Got clips? Love to hear ya! I did a little recording last night, on my Elly Studio. But was kinda drained from our 100-ish temperatures here lately! EDIT: @ Vincent. I meant "Legato Line"... In the context of reasonable control of choosing a good Straight tone note or Vibrato. For hopefully more artistic phrasing/choices.
|
|
|
Post by crillemannen on Sept 9, 2024 14:20:59 GMT -6
I "like" my Voice. But LOVE to sing. Especially live. Live Webinar with Tamplin on Zoom soon. Will let you guys know how it went. EDIT: Tamplin's lean is "Ah" and Forward singing. For Popular Music orientation. He's way into Vowel Modification. Chris P.S. Overall good group meeting. He's planning 4 more... First Saturday each month. 11AM to Noon Pacific Time. For his Monthly Subscribers. Tamplin isn't terrible but there is just to many red flags. I mean what is it with his tongue? That can't be a healthy way of singing haha. And that head falsetto thing he's doing doesn't sound good. I don't know if I've heard any vocal coach that sounds really really good. They're all soso singers. They rarely sound natural.
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Sept 9, 2024 14:52:44 GMT -6
I "like" my Voice. But LOVE to sing. Especially live. Live Webinar with Tamplin on Zoom soon. Will let you guys know how it went. EDIT: Tamplin's lean is "Ah" and Forward singing. For Popular Music orientation. He's way into Vowel Modification. Chris P.S. Overall good group meeting. He's planning 4 more... First Saturday each month. 11AM to Noon Pacific Time. For his Monthly Subscribers. Tamplin isn't terrible but there is just to many red flags. I mean what is it with his tongue? That can't be a healthy way of singing haha. And that head falsetto thing he's doing doesn't sound good. I don't know if I've heard any vocal coach that sounds really really good. They're all soso singers. They rarely sound natural. I've thought that too - what's with the lizard tongue! If I did that I think I'd freak out all the ladies in the crowd! Also, if you watch his "critique" of "Famous singers" on Youtube - he kinda never really gives it up for them and takes little snipes at their technique. I heard him criticizing Sting as being "pitchy" I thought Ken .... you have so missed the point about what makes Sting's amazing!
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 9, 2024 15:36:15 GMT -6
Hey Vincent. Thanks for reminding about Michael Trimble. Being more conscious of "back breathing"... Has already made mid-Register Vibrato generation. Easier. In just ONE day!! EDIT: Now "filtering" these other Instructors through Trimble's teaching. His stuff is already helping me the most! Many thanks, Chris
|
|
|
Post by gwlee7 on Sept 14, 2024 20:00:01 GMT -6
Another thing I like about the person I am working with is that after we work on a song that I am working on for a bit (the current one is Steely Dan’s “Dirty Work” bc the whole melody is right in the notes where I “break”), she then makes me bring my guitar and play them like I will be performing them. She keeps on me about total performance.
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Sept 15, 2024 2:55:06 GMT -6
Retired now but here's my resume: We sang in the car everywhere we went when I was a kid. I sang as a soloist in church starting in 6th grade, sang in school, sang in college, took voice lessons in college, and sang thousands of gigs professionally since, both in GB bands and in vocal ensembles ..in a bunch of genres. A good amount of my experience is with a cappella ensembles where I was a soloist/section leader, ranging from small and doo-wap/rockapella style to mid-sized classical choral ensembles with 8-24 members. All small enough that individual voices make impactful contributions to the sound, which is a nice way of saying one rotten singer can ruin the sound. I have one recommendation: If you can, sing with people who are better than you. My early vocal lessons were all fine and good, but there's nothing like getting out there and seeing and hearing good technique modeled up close and personal. When you're 'singing along' with a better singer, the bar is instantly raised. You learn to match and/or complement their power, tone, vowels, consonants, breathing, intonation, phrasing, and any other aspect of good musicianship you can think of. The good news is in most cases, those musicians want you to get better, and they're more than happy to share their tricks, tips, and insights. Steve Vai said, if you play in a band where you're the best player - your'e in the wrong band! I have always tried to surround myself with super talented people - especially in my band - it's truly the best path to personal improvement.
|
|
|
Post by Vincent R. on Sept 15, 2024 7:11:59 GMT -6
thehightenor great advice. I was very lucky in that regard. I always found myself performing with a handful of people studying with the same teacher. All of us had very different voices. Throughout all of these performances we were always pushing each other to be better. You had to be on your game. skav thank you for the kind words. At my core I’m a belcanto singer. I did use what I learned in the Melocchi technique to understand what I was missing, which was how to relax my larynx. Before those lessons I sang with a larynx little too high. One of the core techniques of that method is the low larynx, and once I understood the sensation, it was very easy to incorporate that into my singing as a whole. Many of the colleagues I was training and working with, and all trained with the same teacher, didn’t have this issue. Most of them came from old-school musical theater. I came from pop music. So that was something I had to work on. What I like about the bel canto style is that it lends itself to many styles. The simple act of broadening the soft palate, or as some people say, singing in the mask, allows for an ease to reach higher notes. In this style singing in the mask is not mutually exclusive from singing with an open throat. We do both, but it’s not as rigid system as the Italian school. It’s a lot looser independent on the singer. It also produces a very natural sounding voice. I find in certain systems that there is a homogenization of vocal timbre. You listen to a bunch of these singers, and they all tend to sound the same. The bel canto style is more like an extension of orator’s speaking voice. It keeps the natural sound of the voice. So if you’ve ever trained an actor to speak in a hall without a microphone while reciting Shakespeare, or the like, this style is a bit of an extension of that.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 15, 2024 13:13:21 GMT -6
Got Trimble’s ebook. Occasional G above Middle C was fine last night. Singing live at a local Art Gallery. * Haven’t developed the skill (yet)…. To totally trust A flat. Hit/miss. More miss. So… Back to the tech “Batting Cage” later today. Chris *Took the lower/Baritone of 3 Part Harmony on… “Don’t Let The Sun Go Down On Me” (Lead vocal has a High A!)
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Sept 15, 2024 15:07:51 GMT -6
I used to have a Db above high C .... not anymore! My range has dropped a few notes as I've aged, but the thickness has increased in a way I really like. I can still make some cool sounds higher up in my mid voice register (ala Mr Sting) but my young high tenor days are behind me The most important thing to master imho. Is airflow/ muscle balance. IME Fricatives are the best way to train getting the air flow right. When you have the airflow spot on you should be able to repeatedly arpeggiate a major/monir chord Tetrad up and down in your mid range for 35 to 40 seconds continuous sound from one breath. That always impresses students :-)
|
|
karlo
Full Member
Posts: 42
|
Post by karlo on Sept 16, 2024 11:18:26 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by antbar on Sept 16, 2024 11:51:01 GMT -6
I have so many lesson tales... my first vocal coach telling me "stick with songwriting, kid... you'll never be a singer!" is a fond memory! Seriously. I wasn't interested in singing anyway, I just wanted to write tunes, so we switched the focus to songwriting and that was fab. Plus, it turns out that songwriting itself helped me improve as a singer over the years.
I took a single piano lesson from Roger Smith, Tower of Power keyboardist. He plonked a huge fake book down on top of the Rhodes and said, "When you get through this, you'll never play that new wave shit again!" I'm 57 now and still playing that new wave shit!
My fav though was asking Kimberley Rew for guitar lessons. Kim of "Walking On Sunshine" fame. I was living in Cambridge, England and he and I were label mates, and had a friendly connection. He came to my gigs, played on my records and had me round for tea from time to time. I suggested a guitar lesson and he said, "Yeah, why not?" Kim is an astonishing player, he's pure energy when he's playing. The two lessons we had were awkward, though. He's a shy fellow and I'm a terrible guitar student. Everything he showed me went over my head. I showed up for a third lesson and said, "Look, why don't we just play some tunes?" He and I were both much happier to do it that way. We played Beatles and Buddy Holly - and truly, I probably learned far more that way than in the actual lessons.
For me, being around amazing players, paying attention to how they work - and also just absorbing Thang through osmosis has been so beneficial.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 16, 2024 22:24:48 GMT -6
Postscript… Using Gallic-Curci’s method (Per Trimble) seems to be the best path (so far) for Breath Management/Support for me…
1) “Back breathing” Free low back “up’. 2) Simultaneous inward low abdominal movement. Then keeping the low abdomen “pasted to the spine” (Curci’s words) 3) Gently “lean” breath out to sing. Against the Sternum. Other great singers had other variations on this method. Chris P.S. Imagining “nothing” above the Chest area, further helps me also Invisible throat/larynx/nose etc. As practiced by Dame Eva Turner. All this is outlined in Trimble’s ebook.
|
|
karlo
Full Member
Posts: 42
|
Post by karlo on Sept 17, 2024 11:29:41 GMT -6
Postscript… Using Gallic-Curci’s method (Per Trimble) seems to be the best path (so far) for Breath Management/Support for me… 1) “Back breathing” Free low back “up’. 2) Simultaneous inward low abdominal movement. Then keeping the low abdomen “pasted to the spine” (Curci’s words) 3) Gently “lean” breath out to sing. Against the Sternum. Other great singers had other variations on this method. Chris P.S. Imagining “nothing” above the Chest area, further helps me also Invisible throat/larynx/nose etc. As practiced by Dame Eva Turner. All this is outlined in Trimble’s ebook. It's astonishing how "conceptual" singing is. "Place" the resonance, "lean", "imagine". What a wack instrument.
|
|
|
Post by skav on Sept 17, 2024 12:12:29 GMT -6
Postscript… Using Gallic-Curci’s method (Per Trimble) seems to be the best path (so far) for Breath Management/Support for me… 1) “Back breathing” Free low back “up’. 2) Simultaneous inward low abdominal movement. Then keeping the low abdomen “pasted to the spine” (Curci’s words) 3) Gently “lean” breath out to sing. Against the Sternum. Other great singers had other variations on this method. Chris P.S. Imagining “nothing” above the Chest area, further helps me also Invisible throat/larynx/nose etc. As practiced by Dame Eva Turner. All this is outlined in Trimble’s ebook. It's astonishing how "conceptual" singing is. "Place" the resonance, "lean", "imagine". What a wack instrument. Hehe! Let me state the obvious.. Other instruments can be opened up, examined and explained visually. Not as simple with a living human body. The singer is both the player and the instrument at the same time. No instrument requires less to play and practice. Most are born with the neccessary parts needed to sing, but still few truly master it. "The eye cannot see the eye" comes to mind.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 17, 2024 17:45:42 GMT -6
Getting farther into Trimble’s ebook…. He’s even talking about great singers where they use… One of several methods, depending on the Operatic Role requirement! Trusting that ‘Rocket” effect of Projection, had been a challenge for me over the years. Nice that we have Pavarotti’s live and recorded performances… As reference for his superb technique. FWIW I decided to keep 90%+ of my live singing around Town… On easy to super easy material. I’m still expected to Belt a little with a Soul Duo. But they are Piano and light Percussion based. So less temptation to “Push”. Chris
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 18, 2024 11:37:08 GMT -6
Am learning also the “Drop Dead” (not literally ) Breathing Method. Useful for me on “Ring of Fire”/Johnny Cash sort of Low Keyed material. Have a nice/solid Deep Bari Low F now on it! (Still not enough Resonance to be a Bass Baritone though) Chris
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 20, 2024 15:35:04 GMT -6
With all due respect to those already posting… So far…. I’ll keep the Tamplin Subscription. But how long TBD. Of course keep Trimble. Any of the other instructors mentioned so far…. Have scratched all but one (haven’t seen his stuff yet) Am still sticking to the Bel Canto “Baby Laugh/Cry”) method of breathing in the back/Sing in the front. Of those like Caruso/Del Monaco/Tucker etc… * Chris * And do my best to avoid conscious modifications of “above the neck”
|
|
|
Post by Vincent R. on Sept 20, 2024 20:34:22 GMT -6
With all due respect to those already posting… So far…. I’ll keep the Tamplin Subscription. But how long TBD. Of course keep Trimble. Any of the other instructors mentioned so far…. Have scratched all but one (haven’t seen his stuff yet) Am still sticking to the Bel Canto “Baby Laugh/Cry”) method of breathing in the back/Sing in the front. Of those like Caruso/Del Monaco/Tucker etc… * Chris * And do my best to avoid conscious modifications of “above the neck” Michael Trimble and I had a great conversation a couple of years back after messaging back and forth a bit. We did have slightly different takes on the breathing, but still what he said helped a bit. He really liked what I was doing with my breathing so he kind of left it alone after giving me a few pointers. A friend of a few of my friends, and really wonderful Italian School tenor posted this video and the snarl as opposed to the yawn position while singing. So, I had to comment, because basically that snarl position is the correct “mask placement” that teachers like Trimble and singers like myself advocate for.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 20, 2024 20:54:01 GMT -6
The snarl is fantastic on…. Stucatto.
|
|
|
Post by poppaflavor on Sept 21, 2024 8:55:09 GMT -6
Oh wow. That Ken Tamplin dude just got totally worked over and exposed for miming/lip syncing fraudulent 'live' streams by Fil from Wings of Pegasus. It's so ridiculously egregious. For his 'live' streams that Fil exposed it's almost like Ken is the cross between Milli Vanilli and that movie Inception as he dips into his past to pirate from previous live streams and even his original recording to lip sync his performance. Fil ends up showing across a couple of videos that Ken not only backtracked himself for a vocal on a current live stream from a live stream of his own that was 4 years ago. He also showed that that live stream from 4 years ago was backtracked by his original album release track! It's shown with video to audio sync where Ken has actually closed his mouth and the vocal is still fading out. Lol it's comically bad. It's also shown by pitch monitoring where Fil can nearly 100% superimpose vocal pitch from 2024 back to 2020 down to the hundredth of a second. So I don't know about the quality of Ken's vocal lessons and instruction, but he's clearly a fraud when it comes to his live streams.
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Sept 21, 2024 9:14:07 GMT -6
The simplest (very effective) thing any singer can do is the Semi- Occluded Vocal Tract exercises by Titze.
It's amazing how well it places the voice and increases efficiently of the all important air/muscle balance.
Also, I've completely moved away from diaphragmatic breathing and now focus/sense intercostal muscles. It's made a huge difference to making breathing technique something I no longer think about and feels very natural.
Singing should feel very natural, I dislike exercises that feel contrived, singing is such a natural effortless thing to do.
The pursuit is unblocking what is entirely natural.
I have a 15 year old female student who has the most perfect natural voice I have ever come across, she is naturally unblocked her technique is perfection as is her pitch - she is what singing naturally is - she's very fascinating in that way.
From day 1 - her very first class - I was relegated to rehearsal pianist - there was nothing I could teach her - just listen and observe in wonder at the natural talent some people are born with.
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 21, 2024 12:27:51 GMT -6
Wow! Awesome. Got clips of her? Thanks, Chris
|
|
|
Post by chessparov on Sept 21, 2024 12:38:54 GMT -6
Oh wow. That Ken Tamplin dude just got totally worked over and exposed for miming/lip syncing fraudulent 'live' streams by Fil from Wings of Pegasus. It's so ridiculously egregious. For his 'live' streams that Fil exposed it's almost like Ken is the cross between Milli Vanilli and that movie Inception as he dips into his past to pirate from previous live streams and even his original recording to lip sync his performance. Fil ends up showing across a couple of videos that Ken not only backtracked himself for a vocal on a current live stream from a live stream of his own that was 4 years ago. He also showed that that live stream from 4 years ago was backtracked by his original album release track! It's shown with video to audio sync where Ken has actually closed his mouth and the vocal is still fading out. Lol it's comically bad. It's also shown by pitch monitoring where Fil can nearly 100% superimpose vocal pitch from 2024 back to 2020 down to the hundredth of a second. So I don't know about the quality of Ken's vocal lessons and instruction, but he's clearly a fraud when it comes to his live streams.
IMHO Ken has an exceptional High Baritone. My guess is that he’s “saving time” for posting vocals. But obviously… It doesn’t excuse that. Much better if he re-Keyed any of these songs. And re-recorded them with his present voice. Even Domingo switched back from Tenor to his original (when he was starting out… High Baritone. I’m in love with the Classical Bel Canto Methods! At least I know enough that at maximum, am a Middleweight Baritone. (With years of further training with a Master ) NEVER could be a Dramatic Baritone in something like Verdi. Let alone Wagner. LOL! Anyway… My sense is there HAS to be some excess Throat tension, going on with Tamplin’s technique.• Yes it sounds “kewl” and Rawk. But Robert Plant screwed up his voice in the 70’s that way. (But the Parties were fun! ) Chris •Oh wiser Singing Brothers… Can anyone sing like Tamplin’s heavy metal voice (his way).., And NOT have any issues?
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Sept 21, 2024 13:52:23 GMT -6
Wow! Awesome. Got clips of her? Thanks, Chris I'd have to ask her permission.
|
|