|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 25, 2015 18:57:36 GMT -6
Could some of you bass playing guys/engineers give me some bass tracking tips? I'm without a DI right now, so I'm not going through my normal chain...but I've been going straight into the Apollo using the unison Neve and LA2A - getting a really nice controlled bass sound. I'm not a bass player - so I don't really know the ins and outs of what leads to a great tone in tracking. I can identify what I think sounds great solo'd up...but as we know, that's not always where it should sit in the mix. What frequencies are you looking for when tracking? Do you put the bass below the kick or above? (frequency wise) How do you normally get the kick and bass to really thump and punch together? That seems to be one of the hardest things ITB for me...
|
|
|
Post by svart on Apr 25, 2015 19:09:27 GMT -6
U47 on an ampeg always works. Center of the dust cap about 8-10" back. Adjust amp to taste.
Kick is always lower, bass is high passed around 75hz, find a place to cut some honk around 200.
Get a good tone with mid harmonics and without resorting to turning up the lows, they won't translate on any modern listening device anyway.
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 25, 2015 19:24:57 GMT -6
No shit? That much?
|
|
|
Post by mrholmes on Apr 25, 2015 19:25:52 GMT -6
For a 60-70s alike Base it always is for me my Hofner straight into my 1073 from there I use Eq and sometimes compression to taste. I do not know if they had DI signals back in the days. But it works. I always get this flat base sound.
|
|
|
Post by warrenfirehouse on Apr 25, 2015 19:39:12 GMT -6
Im do mostly rock/hard rock stuff with dense mixes, so getting the bass/kick huge but tight and defined is crucial. Tracking wise I usually DI through my tonebeast slightly driven into an electra with a slight top lift and mid cut into an ic brute (amazing tracking comp for anything as its hard to push it too hard). The biggest thing that seperates a great bass player for me is one who listens for and controls his own dynamics. If the bass player can "mix himself" on the way in you can use less compression on mixdown and it leads to an overall bigger, more open mix.
Come mixdown, on super dense stuff I will float my bass and kick track to 3 faders. Using hp/lp filters Ill make a bass low centered at 60hz...kick low (80hz)...bass mid(100hz)...kick mid (120hz) and bass high and kick high high passed as necessary. If using a micd bass cab it will be used as bass high with the lows coming from DI. Sometimes i vary the freq center points but you get the idea.
Many ways to skin a cat, but ive gotten my best results this way.
|
|
|
Post by carymiller on Apr 25, 2015 19:42:00 GMT -6
Could some of you bass playing guys/engineers give me some bass tracking tips? I'm without a DI right now, so I'm not going through my normal chain...but I've been going straight into the Apollo using the unison Neve and LA2A - getting a really nice controlled bass sound. I'm not a bass player - so I don't really know the ins and outs of what leads to a great tone in tracking. I can identify what I think sounds great solo'd up...but as we know, that's not always where it should sit in the mix. What frequencies are you looking for when tracking? Do you put the bass below the kick or above? (frequency wise) How do you normally get the kick and bass to really thump and punch together? That seems to be one of the hardest things ITB for me... For tracking: I like to track with a DI splitting the signal, so you get one "clean" DI sound...and one affected if you have effects (distortion/compression/chorus, etc.) I love to reamp bass when I'm given the chance to really dial in great tones FOR the songs against the drum tracks. For Mixing:In terms of dominant frequencies, I think Bass is one of the few instruments where I typically don't notch a little 250Hz out by the end of the mix...because it allows the one instrument that doesn't really feel muddy in that territory to shine. I also tend to cut a little 800Hz-900Hz out so it conflicts with the mid-range of a male vocal less in the mix. This is less important if a woman is singing. Bass tones can really vary...if you've got a brighter sound going on 1.5kHz to 2kHz, or even 3kHz can be a good midrange point to push lightly...usually with a wider bell curve sliding up to 3kHz if the bass needs to be brighter like a guitar (especially if there's distortion engaged.) 4kHz can work too...but usually that's where I like the top end of my guitars to get pushed a bit...so if you go all the way up to 4kHz on the top end of a Bass...maybe bring things down to 2kHz or 3kHz on your guitars so they stand out a bit. 5kHz is where I notchout cymbals...and 6kHz is where I notch out the beater on a kickdrum...I typically cut 7kHz out of everything just a bit when it's possible...and boost a bit of 8kHz on the guitars and strings to add in subharmonics lightly to the upper mid-range. I tend to EQ my two DI tones against each other so the one that's more natural is giving me most of my sub low end boosts. If a shelf curve starting at 200Hz gets engaged here I will typically let it boost down to 24Hz with a sharp Hi-Pass filter lopping off what I just don't need. However sometimes I use the Maag EQ4 (I have the native version by Brainworks) to boost a bit of 10Hz or so even if I engage that Hi-Pass...subharmonically it really adds something. My more distorted bass track tends to get treated mostly like a lower pitched guitar tone...blending with the natural sound. If I can reamp my basic DI...I will run things twice or with an ABY switch on two amps to distort one. I pretty much always use a distorted bass tone in everything...but the percentage of what gets used lowers or increases depending on genre. If it's smooth Jazz for example, a trace amount of that fader will go up just to add a tiny bit of brightness, bite, and meat in the low mids. But in a rock song I might favor the distorted tone and only use enough of the clean one to give me back a bit of sub lowend to push the beat. Every song is different with Bass that way.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 25, 2015 20:15:23 GMT -6
I find it pretty hard to give any guidelines for this. In the good bands i played bass in, we pretty much got out of each others way by choosing the right sounds already in the rehearsal room, so we got out of each way frequencywise as much as we could and had very little problems getting a good PA sound as a band even with shitty FOH mixes. So in studio situation it was pretty easy for me to get a usable tone with a DI and a good pre. Best is if the bass player really knows what he is doing and knows his own sound very good and is aware of what works and what doesn't, also if it comes to bass vs. kick. This goes as far as it goes, down to the composition/arrangement. I mostly prefer a pure DI sound with a bit of tube saturation, sometimes a cab IR and don't reamp for a modern tone. I tried out a bit of LA3A grit sometimes, but i experiment quite a bit with limiters and compressors, in small amounts. This said, i try to keep dynamics under control at the instrument itself. My bass sound is pretty flexible and modern i think, I use my DAWs built-in EQ where i can directly see what happens with an analyzer directly behind the EQ curve, but i mostly get away with mild eqing to fit it in the mix. I try to place the bass clearly above the deep kick in the lows, and give special attention to the finger thumb or plectrum click to maintain clarity and integrity. Sometimes i even give bass some sparkles in the hi-end. It really differs alot with the sound and the song and what happens in guitars and keys. I have quite different approaches, when i mix other peoples bass tracks. Just last weekend i found, that i find it much easier to fit the bass in, when i mix OTB. But however.,,what works, works.
|
|
|
Post by Randge on Apr 25, 2015 20:29:22 GMT -6
I guess I am going for a completely different sound. Bass goes lower than the kick and owns the very bottom end for me. I also distort it (bass) a lot at mix time. The 2nd order harmonics make it cut the track without it having to be too loud in the mix and you don't hear it distort at all. It just sounds very full. I also find some frequencies between 600-900 that will cut my tv and ipad speakers well and be audible in the mix on phones and things. Having a sub and tiny speakers on hand really help resolve questions in the bass. R
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 25, 2015 20:33:47 GMT -6
Btw. i used Bark of Dog/Voice of God quite alot in the last time to give the kick a good pound in the lows. This also makes it easier to find the sweet spot for the bass in the lows afterwards and let them have a better punch together...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 25, 2015 20:36:18 GMT -6
Just saw what Randy posted. Just another proof that there are very different approaches that can lead to good results.
|
|
|
Post by Randge on Apr 25, 2015 20:41:39 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by cowboycoalminer on Apr 25, 2015 21:10:28 GMT -6
Distortion is the key to a punchy bass sound. Sounds awful soloed but killer in a busy mix. Run it through that Sta Level and absolutely punish it. Should be pretty close to done.
|
|
|
Post by jeromemason on Apr 25, 2015 21:41:01 GMT -6
Get a player that can control their dynamics, you know, the waveform looks like it's already been compressed but is raw. Then maybe -5db with mid attack/mid release and I'll put an aux send under it with either deviloc or decapitator. If I use decapitator I'll have it only distort the area of the bass that has the most natural grind, kind of reminds of ringing things out or something, but it does work. I'll pull out what the kick is taking and let the bass be the low of lows. If it's a faster song I'll use a Multband compressor on the bass or sidechain it with the kick. I haven't done that in a while because I've been fortunate to have really good players that can control those types of things, and will think about that kind of stuff when they are tracking. The player, if he's been around the block, can make you look like a genius.
The player is the biggest part though. If you get a spiky player use transient type plugin to kill those and then compress. But EQ before any of it.
That usually let's my bass make it to whatever it's getting played on, usually.
|
|
|
Post by tonycamphd on Apr 25, 2015 22:46:18 GMT -6
no substitution for a great player, great bass. A DI and Amp combo is always the goods. The bottom precedent is dictated by the song, bass, and kick drum. A 26" kick with a jazz bass is all about the kick being on the bottom(think zep), a P-bass with a small kick is all about bass on the bottom, and this is the most common i've seen. I rarely roll off a bass any higher than 30hz. The right amount of distortion gives you midrange presence on a lap top, but i will blow that off if it interferes with other stuff because i could give a rats ass about someone listening on a lap top or cellphone 8) and i really like my bass to drop to the floor, midrange tends to lift the bass up between the speakers...mehhh....
a great way to get kick and bass to work together is to key a multi band comp on the bass track with the kick, and just duck the freq's that mask 8)
|
|
|
Post by mobeach on Apr 26, 2015 6:22:22 GMT -6
Experiment with guitar rigs too, Gary Moore had Bob Daisley play through his Marshall guitar combo while tracking for his biggest selling album.
|
|
|
Post by jayson on Apr 26, 2015 7:34:04 GMT -6
^^This^^ can work surprisingly well. I've been using the amp section of a Fender Hot Rod Deluxe as bass head into an old Carvin 18" "W" style bass bin. I mic that about a foot out from one of the ports with an AKG D-12E. Give a really warm tone that kind of reminds me of some of the bass tones John Paul Jones was getting on the earlier Zep albums. Not a particularly modern sound -not a good match for slapping, popping or Funk-Fingers- but very smooth terra-firma.
I still think the Hi-Z input on a Great River NV is one of the best bass DI sounds that I've heard yet.
|
|
|
Post by Randge on Apr 26, 2015 10:08:25 GMT -6
dandeurloo let me try his DI and I was pretty impressed. They are built like a tank. I gotta get one soon! I really like the Great River DI as well. Fat and tight sounding.
|
|
|
Post by Ward on Apr 26, 2015 10:53:47 GMT -6
U47 on an ampeg always works. Center of the dust cap about 8-10" back. Adjust amp to taste. Kick is always lower, bass is high passed around 75hz, find a place to cut some honk around 200. Get a good tone with mid harmonics and without resorting to turning up the lows, they won't translate on any modern listening device anyway. This and also take a DI signal when you have a DI.
|
|
|
Post by svart on Apr 26, 2015 11:24:47 GMT -6
U47 on an ampeg always works. Center of the dust cap about 8-10" back. Adjust amp to taste. Kick is always lower, bass is high passed around 75hz, find a place to cut some honk around 200. Get a good tone with mid harmonics and without resorting to turning up the lows, they won't translate on any modern listening device anyway. This and also take a DI signal when you have a DI. I always go through my red eye, sometimes i blend in a little DI, but that u47 just works on most of my mixes lately, without a lot of messing around.
|
|
|
Post by swurveman on Apr 26, 2015 12:17:58 GMT -6
Distortion is the key to a punchy bass sound. Sounds awful soloed but killer in a busy mix. Run it through that Sta Level and absolutely punish it. Should be pretty close to done. Cowboy: When you say "distortion" are you talking about pedal distortion or compressor distortion? Or both?
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 26, 2015 12:18:44 GMT -6
Well, I'm talking about me playing...I never have any problem mixing a real bass player...
|
|
|
Post by cowboycoalminer on Apr 26, 2015 12:48:15 GMT -6
Swurve I always use comp distortion. 2 birds with one stone kind of thing but I guess a pedal would work. Kinna the same sound without the note length a compressor adds.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Apr 26, 2015 12:50:31 GMT -6
dandeurloo let me try his DI and I was pretty impressed. They are built like a tank. I gotta get one soon! I really like the Great River DI as well. Fat and tight sounding. Love mine! DI never sounded so good.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Apr 26, 2015 13:09:31 GMT -6
I tend to avoid DI's most of the time, I see lots of amateur players with crappy basses and a DI can accentuate all the problems. Studio standard rig is an Ampeg V4 on a Sunn 6 x 10" cabinet, which is all fairly mid-forward sounding. AKG414 has lived there for awhile, good results from a Joly MJE-K47H also. If there's time/space/reason to go with two mics, it's usually an EV 666 because of the forward 2nd/3rd octave focus it brings. The 666 can be great if the overall approach doesn't call for much fundamental frequency, 666 on both bass and kick can be a classic sound. Sometimes I'll use a crossover approach and split bass in the 90-120Hz range, process or pan differently.
|
|
|
Post by swurveman on Apr 26, 2015 14:10:40 GMT -6
Swurve I always use comp distortion. 2 birds with one stone kind of thing but I guess a pedal would work. Kinna the same sound without the note length a compressor adds. Thanks. I was thinking about those Sans Amp pedals that have "character" buttons which controls the distortion of the sound. I've never had one and wondered about that type of distortion compared to an 1176 or LA2A type compression distortion which I own.
|
|