|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 3, 2024 12:14:31 GMT -6
It will be more linear and better s/n ratio, not certain that will sound like a Prism, but I hope you will be pleased.
|
|
|
Post by Quint on Apr 3, 2024 13:45:00 GMT -6
I've always been curious what might happen after the mod if Universal Audio decides to update the firmware. Does it do a components check like some PCs do? Other than the clock, and that depends on how you view the clock as a component, all of the other mod components are analog components, so there wouldn't really be any parts that could be "checked" by the system. I'm curious about this mod. I've considered it before, but never pulled the trigger. It's not even because I necessarily had any complaints about the sound. It was mostly just FOMO, but that always got cured when I looked at the price and wondered if it actually made a difference. That said, I do own two x16s, so I would actually be able to mod just one and then do a true A/B comparison. That's always been part of my reason for not doing the mod. Before I got a second x16s, I was always put off by the ability to do a real comparison, and was otherwise left to reading opinions or listening to loopback files which were still passing thru my own Apollo. So I never could be convinced to pull the trigger. Maybe one of these days. I'll be curious to see what John thinks.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 3, 2024 14:00:15 GMT -6
Didn’t bla say they don’t mod the 16?
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 3, 2024 14:02:59 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by Martin John Butler on Apr 3, 2024 14:18:36 GMT -6
John, I've never heard a Prism converter, but after my X6 mod, it sounds similar to what Dangerous Music conversion sounds like to me.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 3, 2024 14:22:34 GMT -6
British and Sting is supposed to be a big fan .
|
|
|
Post by wiz on Apr 3, 2024 14:25:01 GMT -6
I've always been curious what might happen after the mod if Universal Audio decides to update the firmware. Does it do a components check like some PCs do? Other than the clock, and that depends on how you view the clock as a component, all of the other mod components are analog components, so there wouldn't really be any parts that could be "checked" by the system. I'm curious about this mod. I've considered it before, but never pulled the trigger. It's not even because I necessarily had any complaints about the sound. It was mostly just FOMO, but that always got cured when I looked at the price and wondered if it actually made a difference. That said, I do own two x16s, so I would actually be able to mod just one and then do a true A/B comparison. That's always been part of my reason for not doing the mod. Before I got a second x16s, I was always put off by the ability to do a real comparison, and was otherwise left to reading opinions or listening to loopback files which were still passing thru my own Apollo. So I never could be convinced to pull the trigger. Maybe one of these days. I'll be curious to see what John thinks. Can you hear a difference between your x8 and x16 converters? cheers Wiz
|
|
|
Post by Mister Chase on Apr 3, 2024 14:38:29 GMT -6
I don't think it's any issue. I'm just looking at it like this: This will be the quality of the Revolution boxes at the very least and I think it's actually a newer mod that goes beyond that. It can be my hub with awesome ADDA or it can be an additional I/O with great ADDA if I decide to expand. Basically, I'm hoping to get "Prism" quality sound with the Apollo front end. I bet it will be great.
|
|
|
Post by Quint on Apr 3, 2024 14:54:02 GMT -6
Other than the clock, and that depends on how you view the clock as a component, all of the other mod components are analog components, so there wouldn't really be any parts that could be "checked" by the system. I'm curious about this mod. I've considered it before, but never pulled the trigger. It's not even because I necessarily had any complaints about the sound. It was mostly just FOMO, but that always got cured when I looked at the price and wondered if it actually made a difference. That said, I do own two x16s, so I would actually be able to mod just one and then do a true A/B comparison. That's always been part of my reason for not doing the mod. Before I got a second x16s, I was always put off by the ability to do a real comparison, and was otherwise left to reading opinions or listening to loopback files which were still passing thru my own Apollo. So I never could be convinced to pull the trigger. Maybe one of these days. I'll be curious to see what John thinks. Can you hear a difference between your x8 and x16 converters? cheers Wiz I've never had any of the 8 channel models. I used to have a silverface 16, and then upgraded to an x16, ultimately adding a second x16.
|
|
|
Post by mjheck on Apr 3, 2024 15:52:16 GMT -6
I think at minimum it raises the floor of the system. Worst case? You have more, higher quality channels to work with, or a fall back should you encounter a technical problem or need service on other components. Best case? it satisfies the quality bar and streamlines the process to how you like to work.
This is ultimately where I ended up. I had my BLA modded rack unit as the centerpiece with a 2192 front end and an Antelope and/or benchmark DAC1 DA. When the power supply went out on my 2192, I found what I lost in sound quality I made up for in speed and ease. I found I mixed worse through the Antelope, and found the modded Apollo and the Benchmark were extremely similar. So I eventually sold all the other components and bought mics.
When I downsized, I just downsized from an BLA Apollo Rack to a BLA Apollo twin. I actually found the headphone outs better on the twin. Probably just a more recent mod, but that was not real subtle.
Anyway, seems like a win win for a lot less money that we spend on most things, yet with the ability to even save some money if it meets or exceeds expectations. Looking forward to hearing how it goes - you certainly have a wealth of experience with which to compare - you will be in a unique position to provide great feedback.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 3, 2024 16:05:53 GMT -6
The 16 had the better top of the line at the time DA, while the Apollo 8 didn’t.
|
|
|
Post by raddistribution on Apr 3, 2024 18:24:39 GMT -6
Didn’t bla say they don’t mod the 16? We definitely mod the x16. It was the last gen black 16 that we didn’t mod
|
|
|
Post by guitfiddler on Apr 3, 2024 20:13:20 GMT -6
Didn’t bla say they don’t mod the 16? We definitely mod the x16. It was the last gen black 16 that we didn’t mod It seems the Blackface 16 mkII would be the one that needs the mod? Is it a different design?
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 4, 2024 1:17:34 GMT -6
Didn’t bla say they don’t mod the 16? We definitely mod the x16. It was the last gen black 16 that we didn’t mod Thx, for the clarification !
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Apr 4, 2024 1:19:50 GMT -6
We definitely mod the x16. It was the last gen black 16 that we didn’t mod It seems the Blackface 16 mkII would be the one that needs the mod? Is it a different design? UA changed the converters each gen, does the X have the dual and better converters and improved clock?
|
|
|
Post by wiz on Apr 8, 2024 19:16:37 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 8, 2024 19:33:36 GMT -6
I’m waiting on it to get back
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 12, 2024 15:40:18 GMT -6
Just got it back this morning...and have been super excited to try it out!
I get it set up enough to take a preliminary listen...and my phone rings. It's my neighbor writhing in pain because he'd just called 911. So I ran over and he had just about cut his big toe off with the lawnmower. It was not what one would describe as "good."
Once the ambulance left, I rejoined my pursuit of sonic bliss (or something that will make me some money) and pushed play...and the image is slightly to the left. Ruh Roh. I'd just been using the Hilo this morning and everything was totally fine. But now, image shifts to the left. So the first thing I did was take the monitor controller out of the path and when I did that, everything was fine and centered. After about 30 minutes, I figure out the $65 Mogami Gold cable on the right monitor out just all of a sudden has less output. Once I replaced that, I could finally switch back and forth between the Apollo modded DA and the Hilo.
I should just get this out of the way: the Apollo no longer has that "bite."
(This is all without the Trinnov in the path.)
And they are super, super close. They sound like brothers, honestly. The Apollo has a little tighter bottom end - and I would say objectively tighter. Listening to Sade "No Ordinary Love." It has this sub synth part all the way through the song. Here's what I mean by "tight." (I'm typing as I listen) The Hilo sounds like it has more sub information, but it sounds like it's smearing a bit. That's probably the wrong word, but it's like slightly out of focus. Sometimes I can get the sense listening to thaat synth bassline that I'm not hearing the attacks as well as on the Apollo. Like it has a tiny bit of diffusion on it...or like when you use a linear EQ and you lose attack on the bottom. BTW - all of this is nitpicking. Both of these units are just killer. As for the top end, the Apollo is still brighter. More presence. It's just enough that you notice it. If I had ONE complaint with the Hilo, it's that it can sound a little boring and flat. Which - hey - you want your DA flat, right? The Apollo is just a tad lifted in comparison. Again - nitpicking. Honestly, I'd rather err on the side of mixes ending up a little less bright...so that doesn't bother me. And which one is more correct? No idea. Again - I'm really talking about small, small differences. I'm not totally sure I could pick these blind...but that's what I think I hear. If I had to say which was the winner for the top, I'd probably say the Hilo handles it a little more effortlessly.
I do love the Hilo - considering it's below $2k for a used one, it's obviously cheaper than buying an Apollo and then the mod. But if I can get away with one interface - just to cut down on all the digital ins and outs etc...and pocket the money from selling the Hilo...that's a win.
|
|
|
Post by wiz on Apr 12, 2024 16:15:05 GMT -6
Just got it back this morning...and have been super excited to try it out! I get it set up enough to take a preliminary listen...and my phone rings. It's my neighbor writhing in pain because he'd just called 911. So I ran over and he had just about cut his big toe off with the lawnmower. It was not what one would describe as "good." Once the ambulance left, I rejoined my pursuit of sonic bliss (or something that will make me some money) and pushed play...and the image is slightly to the left. Ruh Roh. I'd just been using the Hilo this morning and everything was totally fine. But now, image shifts to the left. So the first thing I did was take the monitor controller out of the path and when I did that, everything was fine and centered. After about 30 minutes, I figure out the $65 Mogami Gold cable on the right monitor out just all of a sudden has less output. Once I replaced that, I could finally switch back and forth between the Apollo modded DA and the Hilo. I should just get this out of the way: the Apollo no longer has that "bite." (This is all without the Trinnov in the path.)
And they are super, super close. They sound like brothers, honestly. The Apollo has a little tighter bottom end - and I would say objectively tighter. Listening to Sade "No Ordinary Love." It has this sub synth part all the way through the song. Here's what I mean by "tight." (I'm typing as I listen) The Hilo sounds like it has more sub information, but it sounds like it's smearing a bit. That's probably the wrong word, but it's like slightly out of focus. Sometimes I can get the sense listening to thaat synth bassline that I'm not hearing the attacks as well as on the Apollo. Like it has a tiny bit of diffusion on it...or like when you use a linear EQ and you lose attack on the bottom. BTW - all of this is nitpicking. Both of these units are just killer. As for the top end, the Apollo is still brighter. More presence. It's just enough that you notice it. If I had ONE complaint with the Hilo, it's that it can sound a little boring and flat. Which - hey - you want your DA flat, right? The Apollo is just a tad lifted in comparison. Again - nitpicking. Honestly, I'd rather err on the side of mixes ending up a little less bright...so that doesn't bother me. And which one is more correct? No idea. Again - I'm really talking about small, small differences. I'm not totally sure I could pick these blind...but that's what I think I hear. If I had to say which was the winner for the top, I'd probably say the Hilo handles it a little more effortlessly. I do love the Hilo - considering it's below $2k for a used one, it's obviously cheaper than buying an Apollo and then the mod. But if I can get away with one interface - just to cut down on all the digital ins and outs etc...and pocket the money from selling the Hilo...that's a win. congrats ... bet you sh*t yer pants when the image was off... 8).... really glad it worked out for you bud! Do they mod the AD as well? cheers Wiz
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 12, 2024 16:20:04 GMT -6
XB Mod (Premium Analog I/O & XB Clock)
Analog
– New, high performance op-amps on all analog inputs and outputs – New, high-grade signal path capacitors on analog inputs (not available on X16) – New, high-grade decoupling capacitors on mic preamps, Hi-Z inputs, and headphone amplifiers (not available on X16) – New, high-grade decoupling capacitors on line outputs (X16 only) – New, high-grade decoupling capacitors used for global power filtration – Improving the performance of the analog stage circuits makes a drastic difference for tracking, mixing, and mastering (expect amazing micro-dynamics and space)! Digital
– New internal, ultra-low-jitter, XB word clock with proprietary implementation – The clock modification makes a big difference to the A/D and D/A conversion stages. It opens up the soundstage and removes grit! – Proprietary decoupling on all A/D and D/A converters using methods found in our Signature, FM, and XB modifications – Our approach to converter decoupling reduces noise generated during the conversion process, leaving you with crisp, clear audio!
Noticed this immediately
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 16,083
|
Post by ericn on Apr 12, 2024 16:30:55 GMT -6
Glad you like it, sorry about your neighbor.
The thing about these mods is every time I sit with someone like Savart, who has designed converters or interfaces it’s always “ this isn’t rocket surgery, most of these mods are really for the most part building it the way the original prototype was built. It’s all about how do we hit the price point??” As a consumer it kind of sucks and knowing guys who have been part of the design teams of some of our favorite manufacturers and some our favorite targets to slag, I know its absolutely true.
|
|
|
Post by veggieryan on Apr 12, 2024 16:37:26 GMT -6
Thanks for the update. Sounds like a good value.
Curious to hear your thoughts on how the AD sounds now... would also be great if it could improve the microphone preamps, hi-z inputs and headphone amps which are mediocre at best on my x6 to my ears....
|
|
|
Post by wiz on Apr 12, 2024 16:56:43 GMT -6
Thanks for the update. Sounds like a good value. Curious to hear your thoughts on how the AD sounds now... would also be great if it could improve the microphone preamps, hi-z inputs and headphone amps which are mediocre at best on my x6 to my ears.... Good point, the headphone amps on my x8 are to me its weakest link. I added a custom built dual headphone amp a couple of interfaces before the Apollo... good investment.. Interesting point about the mods bringing the design up to spec.... cheers Wiz
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 12, 2024 17:04:55 GMT -6
I listened (I use a Hearback system) and it's louder, with less distortion.
|
|
|
Post by Quint on Apr 12, 2024 17:11:42 GMT -6
Just got it back this morning So the mod on the Apollo x6 was worth the money? Listening to Sade "No Ordinary Love." What kind of wine were you drinking?
|
|