Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 14, 2023 14:19:48 GMT -6
I must be dumb. Because I'm getting a worse result with it on than off. It’s for aligning multi miced instruments like two mics on a guitar cab or a snare without having to break out an oscilloscope and a delay like Steve Albini. Anything else is just nutty. Kinda like how crappy “producers” use Soothe on instruments and their tracks sound like they’ve just been run through bad, high end detail killing gear (a bunch of Behringer channels costs the same) rather than have any the issues fixed. Soon there will be “auto align live” for bad drummers just like bad pop stars use auto tune live and there’s “soothe live”
|
|
|
Post by M57 on Apr 14, 2023 14:49:31 GMT -6
I must be dumb. Because I'm getting a worse result with it on than off. It’s for aligning multi miced instruments like two mics on a guitar cab or a snare without having to break out an oscilloscope and a delay like Steve Albini. So this should make a difference if you're micing a piano with three or 4 mics, right? How does it work? I.e, does it pick one as a reference and align the others to the reference?
|
|
|
Post by jcoutu1 on Apr 14, 2023 15:45:09 GMT -6
It’s for aligning multi miced instruments like two mics on a guitar cab or a snare without having to break out an oscilloscope and a delay like Steve Albini. So this should make a difference if you're micing a piano with three or 4 mics, right? How does it work? I.e, does it pick one as a reference and align the others to the reference? Exactly. I only used V1, but that’s the concept. Pick the source and align tracks to that. Should be great for your purpose.
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 14, 2023 15:59:56 GMT -6
I must be dumb. Because I'm getting a worse result with it on than off. It’s for aligning multi miced instruments like two mics on a guitar cab or a snare without having to break out an oscilloscope and a delay like Steve Albini. Anything else is just nutty. Kinda like how crappy “producers” use Soothe on instruments and their tracks sound like they’ve just been run through bad, high end detail killing gear (a bunch of Behringer channels costs the same) rather than have any the issues fixed. Soon there will be “auto align live” for bad drummers just like bad pop stars use auto tune live and there’s “soothe live” I understand. They’re just saying you can use it with snare feeding to Tom’s and overhead, etc. I can see putting it on snare and hat maybe. Also does great things with multi miked acoustics.
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker on Apr 15, 2023 5:49:54 GMT -6
You should only be putting this on the audio tracks with the audio you wish to align. If you're working with a multi track session setup where the drums were tracks seperately from everything, should only use it on Drums. If you live tracked something with bass and guitar in the room then add those. Other wise there isn't any point to align a bass track to the drums that weren't in the same space with multiple mics. right yeah, but it automatically groups things for you. So I strapped it on everything when I tested it, and it knew that the bass amp/di were tracked separate from the drums so it groups them into two unique groups, aligns the drums by themselves and aligns the bass amp to the di by its self. the key is the auto grouping it does, it analyzes the data and knows what was tracked at the same time and groups those. I went very heavy handed when first testing it and just followed the manual instructions, there might be a case for moving the key track around manually or removing some stuff from being aligned. need to experiment more with it next week. but im tracking a band this weekend and going to try and get my phase right at the source like some lame luddite
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 15, 2023 11:00:48 GMT -6
I gotta be honest...I'm not getting dramatic results. Maybe the stuff I'm testing it on is already well set up and phase aligned. I've just been trying to align Snare, Snare BTM, HH, TOMS and OH...and maybe I hear a difference? Even when I just go down to just aligning top and bottom snare, it seems like it loses bottom end when it's ON. I know it's really for single multi miked instruments - but they're selling it like you can slap it on a drum kit and it's smart enough to figure everything out. Hasn't been my experience. It does do good things for like a stereo miked Acoustic - but I can do that with V1.
|
|
|
Post by drumrec on Apr 15, 2023 11:07:18 GMT -6
Can only say to those who work in LUNA that Auto Align 2 cannot save its settings after you have saved and then opened again!
|
|
|
Post by drumrec on Apr 15, 2023 11:27:46 GMT -6
I gotta be honest...I'm not getting dramatic results. Maybe the stuff I'm testing it on is already well set up and phase aligned. I've just been trying to align Snare, Snare BTM, HH, TOMS and OH...and maybe I hear a difference? Even when I just go down to just aligning top and bottom snare, it seems like it loses bottom end when it's ON. I know it's really for single multi miked instruments - but they're selling it like you can slap it on a drum kit and it's smart enough to figure everything out. Hasn't been my experience. It does do good things for like a stereo miked Acoustic - but I can do that with V1. It does no magic if the files are well in phase. When I mix other people's files and sometimes there are a lot of drum tracks that are completely out of phase. Then AA2 comes in handy and does its magic. The drums in my studio I have the mics in the same place mostly and have moved them around carefully for the phase. So I don't get much use out of AA2 when I'm recording myself, but a time saver for other people's jobs when it's completely out of phase. So I assume you've got good drums in phase that you're testing on.
|
|
|
Post by Blackdawg on Apr 15, 2023 22:12:24 GMT -6
I gotta be honest...I'm not getting dramatic results. Maybe the stuff I'm testing it on is already well set up and phase aligned. I've just been trying to align Snare, Snare BTM, HH, TOMS and OH...and maybe I hear a difference? Even when I just go down to just aligning top and bottom snare, it seems like it loses bottom end when it's ON. I know it's really for single multi miked instruments - but they're selling it like you can slap it on a drum kit and it's smart enough to figure everything out. Hasn't been my experience. It does do good things for like a stereo miked Acoustic - but I can do that with V1. Haven't tried the new one yet. But for me yes sometimes it isn't better. But for me with drums sometimes it feels like it's worse. But then I notice the imaging and focus of the sound and it's way better. But it's not a magic wand I'm sure. Sometimes it's gonna work great. Other times it's not. Plus isn't most your stuff can drums?
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Apr 16, 2023 8:12:59 GMT -6
I gotta be honest...I'm not getting dramatic results. Maybe the stuff I'm testing it on is already well set up and phase aligned. I've just been trying to align Snare, Snare BTM, HH, TOMS and OH...and maybe I hear a difference? Even when I just go down to just aligning top and bottom snare, it seems like it loses bottom end when it's ON. I know it's really for single multi miked instruments - but they're selling it like you can slap it on a drum kit and it's smart enough to figure everything out. Hasn't been my experience. It does do good things for like a stereo miked Acoustic - but I can do that with V1. Haven't tried the new one yet. But for me yes sometimes it isn't better. But for me with drums sometimes it feels like it's worse. But then I notice the imaging and focus of the sound and it's way better. But it's not a magic wand I'm sure. Sometimes it's gonna work great. Other times it's not. Plus isn't most your stuff can drums? None of my stuff I work on is canned drums
|
|
|
Post by M57 on Apr 16, 2023 8:31:15 GMT -6
I just downloaded this for a 14 day trail and have been experimenting with it using simple set-up on a baby grand. One SDC stereo pair about 11” apart over the hammers and one LDC ~ 24” away from the pair and toward the back close to an edge.
I recorded multiple passes of similar performances, and also slow scales across the entire keyboard to make it easy to A/B individual notes. Here are my initial thoughts.
The’re no mistaking that this thing is making a difference. Re-aligned tracks sound dramatically different. At first I was a bit confused. Higher notes do ring brighter and cleaner, but notes in the mid-range (G2-C4) sounded dull and less dimensional to me. Multiple takes of different material and re-alignments confirmed this, but over time my ears started to get use to it, and I began to realize that out of phase mid-range notes just have more “buzz” to them (for lack of a better word), and I may have been confusing phasing with brighter. It’s taken some time for me but I’m coming to the realization that the mid-range is cleaner with alignment on, and though I haven’t played with it much I’ve had some success putting the ‘bright’ back in with eq.
I do have a number of crits.
The owners manual may be pretty, but it’s mostly worthless. E.g. There’s a wonderful diagram on page 12 enumerating the buttons/features on the gui ..and then.. there’s NO outlined description of what they do! Now granted, there’s not much to the thing, but I did have to futz with it to figure out how to use it.
They don’t want you to tweak the offsets - or anything for that matter.. There’s no middle ground. No adjusting. You either accept their sorcery or you don’t.
When I record multiple takes on a different set of tracks, even if I manually group them separately, the program wants to off-set them against each other. My solution is to analyze and print each group one at a time. Then reset, rinse and repeat. I may be missing something here, but the manual is no help. The thing has a mind of its own.
My plan for the moment is to put it through its paces on a few projects over the remainder of the trial period. I really want to buy this, but $200 is way more than I want to spend on a non-VI plugin.
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Jun 19, 2023 19:29:32 GMT -6
I just demoed this and I think I’m sold. I often put 15 mics on a drum kit, so this makes my life a lot easier than toying with Waves’ In Phase for 20 min.
Now my only question is if I drop the extra $200 to get Pi and Surfer EQ
|
|
|
Post by theshea on Jun 20, 2023 3:19:55 GMT -6
anyone compared this to melda MAutoAlign? that's way cheaper ... if it works just as good. anyone knows?
|
|
|
Post by christophert on Jun 20, 2023 4:17:40 GMT -6
I just demoed this and I think I’m sold. I often put 15 mics on a drum kit, so this makes my life a lot easier than toying with Waves’ In Phase for 20 min. Now my only question is if I drop the extra $200 to get Pi and Surfer EQ So how did you find the best way for you to get a good outcome? Treat different elements as sets of phase corrections? Align everything to the OH's - or align everything to the kick and snare ?
It seems like there are many ways to do it, and not any info on the best approach for drums on this new version.
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Jun 20, 2023 9:34:39 GMT -6
I just demoed this and I think I’m sold. I often put 15 mics on a drum kit, so this makes my life a lot easier than toying with Waves’ In Phase for 20 min. Now my only question is if I drop the extra $200 to get Pi and Surfer EQ I’m convinced that Pi on my kick and bass improves things.
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Jun 20, 2023 10:58:41 GMT -6
I just demoed this and I think I’m sold. I often put 15 mics on a drum kit, so this makes my life a lot easier than toying with Waves’ In Phase for 20 min. Now my only question is if I drop the extra $200 to get Pi and Surfer EQ So how did you find the best way for you to get a good outcome? Treat different elements as sets of phase corrections? Align everything to the OH's - or align everything to the kick and snare ?
It seems like there are many ways to do it, and not any info on the best approach for drums on this new version.
I made my own groups. I don't think I even realized it did so automatically. I didn't notice much difference in my guitars, but that's because I already put them through In Phase (only use two mics per pass). I grouped all drums together, aside from overheads, who I did not include purposely.
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Jun 20, 2023 12:22:40 GMT -6
I just demoed this and I think I’m sold. I often put 15 mics on a drum kit, so this makes my life a lot easier than toying with Waves’ In Phase for 20 min. Now my only question is if I drop the extra $200 to get Pi and Surfer EQ I’m convinced that Pi on my kick and bass improves things. i remember not noticing a huge difference last time I demoed it. just shot them an email to see if they'll let me demo again.
|
|
|
Post by tasteliketape on Jun 20, 2023 13:23:22 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by Johnkenn on Jun 20, 2023 14:04:07 GMT -6
I’m convinced that Pi on my kick and bass improves things. i remember not noticing a huge difference last time I demoed it. just shot them an email to see if they'll let me demo again. I didn't say it DID, I just said I'm convinced it does lol
|
|
|
Post by paulcheeba on Jun 20, 2023 17:39:58 GMT -6
Unbelievable tool. Shockingly useful. Been using it on my new drum libraries and the results are terrific.
|
|
|
Post by theshea on Jun 20, 2023 23:23:53 GMT -6
thanks. gonna check the demo. EDIT: checked the demo and it did not work properly. did not recognice or ignore some tracks in a drum multitrack recording, whereas melda mauto align worked right away with one click and delivered punchier clearer drums. wanted to try the radix auto-aligne 2 demo but the homepage did not let me register ... they seem to do all the same, analyzing and calcolating sample distances ... so don't know if radix is woth the hefty price vs. melda which is around 49 euros.
|
|
|
Post by theshea on Jun 21, 2023 4:30:47 GMT -6
ok did some testing on drums, drums with added samples, piano recorded with 2 mics, bass DI plus bass amp with 2 mics, acoustic guitar recorded with 2 mics.
melda mautoalign and radix auto-align 2 both worked nicely and gave about the same audio results, although they delivered different numbers and took different tracks as reference. but the end result sounded very good on both.
with the click of a button! 5-10 seconds! now thats workflow!
the bass DI combined with the recorded amp with 2 mics was dramatically improvement! sounded very very good - with the click of a button! i couldn‘t get it better manually. and it took me more time.
piano recorded with 2 mics sounded more roomy and notes clearer.
even an acoustic guitar recorded with 2 mics - one close one further away - sounded improved and we all know the player moves while playing.
so yes, i am gonna buy melda mauto align as i can‘t justify spending 4 times as much for radix auto align 2. to me they sound the same. could i do it manually? yes, but it takes more time.
|
|
|
Post by chipbuttie on Jun 21, 2023 6:55:57 GMT -6
Unbelievable tool. Shockingly useful. Been using it on my new drum libraries and the results are terrific. Do you align to kick or snare and do you include overheads?
|
|
|
Post by paulcheeba on Jun 21, 2023 15:37:31 GMT -6
Unbelievable tool. Shockingly useful. Been using it on my new drum libraries and the results are terrific. Do you align to kick or snare and do you include overheads? It’s kind of automatic version 2 no? Manually I do it to snare.
|
|
|
Post by chipbuttie on Jun 22, 2023 8:13:01 GMT -6
Do you align to kick or snare and do you include overheads? It’s kind of automatic version 2 no? Manually I do it to snare. Automatically it seems to pick either snare or kick but there is the option to choose any track you like. Ive been playing around with it. In the 2 songs I tried it on it wasn’t a huge difference, the snare had a little more focus abd the kit as a whole sounded a little further forward. It lost some depth though, it felt a little more natural with it off. Both songs were from the same session.
|
|