|
Post by jmoose on May 9, 2022 14:08:01 GMT -6
I love all the comments from folks offering sage studio advice like angled walls, etc. but you have to remember you're dealing with a functioning garage your wife will drive in and out of. It's not going to be the best studio, but can be a fun rehearsal studio. But please stop overthinking this. Well that's the thing right? Intent. If the room has to also function as a regular garage I get it... but then there's no point in the time & expense of angling walls & building in trapping etc. Unless the room is completely sealed none of it is going to work. The whole point of building like that is to control sound and make the reflections do what we want. Can't do that if one wall is basically open air. If it has to also be a garage to park & keep the lawnmower in then might as well keep costs down & concentrate on making it a comfortable space. There's also the expense factor. Yeah its possible to convert a garage & completely soundproof it. Did one 10-12 years ago for a friend. Close the door and it sounds like there's a radio playing in the background. Meanwhile on the other side of the wall, bass player has an SVT at proper volume... full drums etc. Took about $40-45k to get there in 2010 money. Given the cost of materials today? Easily more. Lumber is back up again. Bought some plywood last week wow.
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on May 9, 2022 22:05:11 GMT -6
Just because we plan to occasionally pull a car into the space is not a big deal. We have a 3rd garage bay for other stuff, and storage around the side of the house that we will be building a cover for.. so no there will not be lawn mowers, garbage cans, etc.in this space. My buddy has a similar setup and he only pulls the car in during the winter. You would never know that if you didn’t see it first hand. My point is don’t write me off just because I want to leave the option available! I will be drawing up preliminary plans soon (I’m a structural engineer by trade) and once I get something started, let the games begin!
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on May 10, 2022 11:19:12 GMT -6
Okay, here is my first take on a space planning draft (hopefully the image uploads!) Edit, I am not sure how to directly insert an image but the link appears to be working. ibb.co/m0HD9MRI measured the space and it is a bit smaller than I had thought so I am stealing a bit of space from the adjacent motorcycle garage. To save space I have shown the PA speakers mounted in the angled walls above the guitar rigs. Thoughts? I am treating this more of a tracking room than just a jam room, but with the ability to have a full band session. I am very strongly considering building Ian's 12 channel EZTubeMixer for this project. Any ideas how to maybe do some screening on the drum kit to keep the drum SPL under control without compromising sounds quality? Anyway let me know your thoughts!
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on May 10, 2022 11:47:58 GMT -6
My first thoughts are that even though you have an angled wall and one splayed wall, you still have an essentially 19x19’ square room which is a horrible dimension ratio (1:1) for acoustics. You should type in the dimensions on a room mode calculator to figure the best starting point. Or pay for a consult from a professional.
Angles, and/or splayed walls are great, but if they’re done in an arbitrary fashion you won’t get any reduction in room modes, you’ll just make them harder to calculate.
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on May 10, 2022 12:29:50 GMT -6
Yes definitely good thoughts. I will be doing exactly that.
Any recommendations on who to consult with?
I also emailed GIK to get their feedback as I bought all the treatment for the control room from them last year.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on May 10, 2022 12:45:42 GMT -6
Jeff Hedback is highly regarded, I’ve never used his services myself but many on this forum have. I hear he’s very affordable and I’m sure his advice is worth is weight in gold.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on May 10, 2022 13:45:33 GMT -6
Jeff Hedback is highly regarded, I’ve never used his services myself but many on this forum have. I hear he’s very affordable and I’m sure his advice is worth is weight in gold. X2. Worth his weight in gold cubed..... Jeff is adept at working in problem rooms. But honestly saying that : "Just because we plan to occasionally pull a car into the space is not a big deal." Honestly, it's more than a big deal. It's a huge deal, and IMO, a dealbreaker, but please, don't take our word for it. Shoot for your dreams. Report back. <thumbsup>
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on May 10, 2022 15:09:07 GMT -6
Ok, sent Jeff an email!
|
|
|
Post by Ned Ward on May 10, 2022 19:09:42 GMT -6
Sofabeds suck. They're a horrible compromise at trying to be a good sofa and a good bed. I always tell people not to go for the "sofa bed option"...
For a mixing room, get nearfield monitors and stands next to the mixer. You can't really mix with speakers that far away effectively. Learn to build bass traps and you can create a rolling gobo/bass trap for mixing - if you're handy with pocket screws and 1x4 wood, you'll save a ton of money and have some versatile options. These can also be used to help minimize bleed between drums and guitar, etc. during tracking.
For a rehearsal room, having the speakers where you have them is a recipe for vocal mic feedback disaster. You really want the speakers on the wall facing you - not like how you'd be live. Or is the idea to have a "stage" to play to friends sitting on the couch? If that's the case, speakers on those wall mount stands ahead of where you're playing + floor monitors will do the trick. Hard to tell given the layout.
I think it can be a fun space, and glad to see you'll have a floating/raised floor for the drums. Look for online suggestions on building a decoupled drum riser that not only gives you elevation, but decouples the kick from the floor.
I'd also suggest toeing in the amps at a greater angle or almost perpendicular - easier for the band to hear each other and keep the volume low without monitor mixes, etc.
Auralex GRAMMA - I have three of these for my amps - it acoustically decouples your amp from the floor to reduce the bass coupling effect, but also gets rid of everything in the house rattling when you play the amp. They're inexpensive, portable, and they have several sizes for each amp. Worth the investment.
How is your power down there? Want to look at avoiding ground loops. While you're building walls, why not put in big conduit to pull snakes, etc.. You can have all your drum and amp mics off a snake and have the wiring in the walls to clean up the space.
Looking forward to more!
|
|
|
Post by Guitar on May 11, 2022 7:52:22 GMT -6
A few random thoughts, once you get the big stuff sorted, acoustically treat the live room a bit, makes a big difference in the pleasure of playing in there.
If you have Windows you can use "Remote Desktop" on a second computer to operate the upstairs computer, to record with. Can be a pretty generic, cheap computer, it's just a control surface. Snakes are great, I use one called XS Pro I think, from Amazon, pretty inexpensive, it's been reliable for years. This is how I track drums in another room.
Another obvious option is to use a laptop based system in the live room to record with, with Reaper or something, whatever, then just transfer the session to the upstairs system.
Or a Sound Devices / Zoom type rig would work too, if you're not doing a lot of editing, punch ins, etc, just live tracking, and if it's a small enough number of tracks.
Getting the "OK" on a second room is a huge deal, congratulations! I'd hope one day I could get the same blessing.
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on May 11, 2022 11:50:13 GMT -6
Great idea on the laptop controller!
I haven’t really thought through it but I was imagining having a video cam/screen in both rooms for tracking sessions to act as “the window”.
On jam nights I’m thinking I would just hit record and let it roll all night but a remote desktop deal would be much better.
|
|
|
Post by Ned Ward on May 11, 2022 17:37:09 GMT -6
Video cameras with monitors is how Primus recorded "My name is mud" at their house back in the day of ADATs... Getting one of those TASCAM mixers that you can just add a USB Stick and record all the channels would make Jam night more focused on fun. Not sure if the TASCAM or Zoom has better preamps... With a few splitters, you can have the mixer downstairs set for jam night, and then record upstairs using preamps you want... audiopile-net.3dcartstores.com/MST-412-AAudiopile makes great stuff and you could add as you go. I have no affiliation with Audiopile other than being a happy customer with them.
|
|
ztime
New Member
Posts: 12
|
Post by ztime on Aug 19, 2022 1:21:37 GMT -6
It’s going to be mostly hard rock and old school ish metal. I’m not too worried about neighbors, we know everyone well and we will definitely do some treatment but I’m primarily concerned about sound quality. Anyone can recommend a few models of analog mixers to look in to? You had some great advice for the room treatment, just remember angled walls and ceilings are desirable but will lessen the useful space size. Building bass traps (I mean proper bass traps, permanently build in) can be great. I would also recommend Korg MW-1608 or 2408 mixer(s). Best of luck, it's a great fun - project! :-)
|
|
|
Post by tahoebrian5 on Aug 19, 2022 8:40:47 GMT -6
It’s taking a lot longer to get to this than I had hoped. I’m almost finished with my kitchen remodel, then it’s build a covered storage area on the side of the house to put all the stuff that is currently in the garage into, then I can finally get started.
|
|
|
Post by jeremygillespie on Aug 19, 2022 8:58:42 GMT -6
It’s taking a lot longer to get to this than I had hoped. I’m almost finished with my kitchen remodel, then it’s build a covered storage area on the side of the house to put all the stuff that is currently in the garage into, then I can finally get started. I hear that. I’ve been doing a whole house Reno that’s taking me forever, and I’ve got the barn out back that will be the studio.... in due time. Gotta coax the bats out first though! And get the house done before my wife murders me hahaha
|
|
|
Post by Ned Ward on Aug 19, 2022 9:00:30 GMT -6
Happy wife, happy life... glad you have priorities in order...
|
|
ztime
New Member
Posts: 12
|
Post by ztime on Aug 19, 2022 12:48:46 GMT -6
It’s taking a lot longer to get to this than I had hoped. I’m almost finished with my kitchen remodel, then it’s build a covered storage area on the side of the house to put all the stuff that is currently in the garage into, then I can finally get started. That's a good plan :-) Best of luck!
|
|
|
Post by jcoutu1 on Aug 20, 2022 8:06:29 GMT -6
It’s taking a lot longer to get to this than I had hoped. I’m almost finished with my kitchen remodel, then it’s build a covered storage area on the side of the house to put all the stuff that is currently in the garage into, then I can finally get started. Your drum riser looks too small to get a kit onto comfortably. Especially if you've got a rock drummer.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Aug 20, 2022 10:08:45 GMT -6
Have a friend who got a Hedbeck design for an existing small room in his house with one iso, then got the build quoted last month. $80k-120k depending on materials fluctuations, avg’d at $350/sq ft. I don’t know if budget constraints were part of the design conversation.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Aug 20, 2022 13:55:56 GMT -6
Have a friend who got a Hedbeck design for an existing small room in his house with one iso, then got the build quoted last month. $80k-120k depending on materials fluctuations, avg’d at $350/sq ft. I don’t know if budget constraints were part of the design conversation. The cost of construction - even if you're doing it yourself - has gone thru the ROOF!!! We'll have to wait to see if it ever settles back down again...
|
|
|
Post by jeremygillespie on Aug 21, 2022 17:25:55 GMT -6
8’ - 2x4 Doug fir studs are back down to about $5.25 again. At peak they tapped out at around $13 a pop. That was truly insane. Especially since you’d toss about 1/4 of the skid aside cause they were more crooked than... well whatever, they were total shit and useless to build with.
Windows are pretty nuts as well. My wait time currently is about 3.5 months, and they are running me at or around 1k a pop. Granted I got the super high end Anderson’s, but it’s a forever home so we said fuck it and bit the bullet.
Crazy times.
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 16,059
Member is Online
|
Post by ericn on Sept 18, 2022 16:08:48 GMT -6
I’ve been thinking of using a splitter snake so everything gets piped upstairs to the ferrofish 16 for recording, then only split out what is needed in the PA so small simple mixer and eq for any feedback cuts needed. Only fx needed will be on vox I think, and I can generate these thru the Axefx3 on in/out ch2. The angled wall idea has my wheels turning. Wondering about building the pa monitors into the wall more like recording studio mains. Rather than a splitter snake consider audio over Ethernet, then your putting $ into interface not cable!
|
|