|
Post by chazman on Sept 3, 2016 17:43:03 GMT -6
Got a sweet ten today, and placed it in my 4-slot desktop rack. Once hooked up, noticed a hum when preamps were plugged in and routed to an output in my mix. Went through a bunch of steps of trouble shooting, moving preamps (both CAPI and HA), cables, channel slots, etc. The sound was even there when Sweet Ten was powered off. As long as preamp was connected, it was there. As a last resort, I pulled the ST out and connected it a couple feet away from the rack and the sound was gone. To test the theory I pulled the power conditioner out of the rack and confirmed it was creating the hum that was being picked up. However, I have 2x of teh same exact power strip at the top of both racks and after pulling out one, I noticed a tiny bit coming from the OTHER as well! Check out video here: www.dropbox.com/s/doq41jum4k...n-Hum.mov?dl=0Is this normal or an issue with the Sweet Ten? If so, is it due to this unit only or the product itself? Anyone else ever had this issue with any other 500-series chassis and nearby power strips? Not liking the idea of having to house power further away, so any insight would be greatly appreciated.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 3, 2016 17:53:32 GMT -6
I've not had it with any 500 series racks or supplies, but I have with many other types of gear. Sometime I've even had to turn the offending piece 90 degrees to get it to go away. Isn't electricity fun?!?!?!?
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 3, 2016 17:55:18 GMT -6
PS - clean power, proper grounding, telescoped leads, wood or isolated rack rails, no gear touching, etc. are a starting place. Relocating gear next. Voodoo as a last resort.....
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 3, 2016 19:56:43 GMT -6
drbill...thank for the reply! Do you think another make 500 series chassis could possibly behave different in my set-up?
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 14,978
Member is Online
|
Post by ericn on Sept 3, 2016 20:56:06 GMT -6
drbill...thank for the reply! Do you think another make 500 series chassis could possibly behave different in my set-up? Try using a 3 to 2 prong ground lift cheater adaptor and see if that works first then try the modules in each slot to see if it's all the slots or just one.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 3, 2016 20:57:42 GMT -6
It's hard to know. I'd look to make sure you have your electrical and wiring dialed in first. That said, in fully "analog", old school (console, tape machines, much outboard, etc.) this would not be an uncommon problem. Electrical, hums, ground noise, upper harmonic noise etc., can often be very tricky to analyze and fix. Sometimes it's something simple, other times, like I said - voodoo.....
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Sept 3, 2016 21:38:40 GMT -6
More likely the transformer coupled pre's than the rack. But every situation is different.
|
|
|
Post by mulmany on Sept 3, 2016 23:11:01 GMT -6
Can you take the lid off the rack Power unit?
If you can, check and make sure that it, the lid, is making electrical contact with the rest of the chasis.
You can do the same with the Sweet 10.
Sounds like a shielding issue.
What happens if you put just a regular power strip next to the preamps?
Is it all units in the rack? Just one?
Just reread what you wrote... the rack Power strips are producing an audible hum?
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 4, 2016 1:52:29 GMT -6
More likely the transformer coupled pre's than the rack. But every situation is different. Could you explain what you mean by this? Thx!
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 4, 2016 2:00:47 GMT -6
Did some more troubleshooting. Swapped out hte power conditioner for another older one I had and the hum was reduced. However, I also bypassed all of the power strips and went down to floor strips I had which didn't completely eliminate it either, but was about the same as when I used the older strip mentioned above. What's most intriguing to me is that the humm is louder when the unit is completely powered off. After it goes through a slow power off sequence, the hum comes in louder than when it's being powered!
As a final test I compared the hum against a Heritage Audio OST-4 box I have and had none of the hum...obviously it's not milometers from a rackable power strip, but in my ind it's either the specific unit I have or the construction of the Sweet Ten model itself. Gonna call the vendor and get another brand chassis sent out to test in the same position. I liked the PA ST cause it has internal power and ability to expand into a summing mixer. But alas, got the rest of my preamps coming Wednesday, so it's more important to me to have something that isn't finicky!
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Sept 4, 2016 8:02:45 GMT -6
Transformers induce hum in other transformers.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 4, 2016 10:39:22 GMT -6
To me sounds like a system problem, not a specific sweet 10 problem. But without testing and being there, it's impossible to tell. I'd be willing to bet your next sweet 10 does the same thing.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Sept 4, 2016 11:08:07 GMT -6
I own two Sweet Tens and they work perfectly. The rack they sit in home-runs to the power conditioner along with everything else so I guess thats a star configuration. My racks are metal, and everything is crammed together. Maybe I'm lucky, but I have no line hum at all.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 4, 2016 11:40:33 GMT -6
No a Star config is much more involved than that. But glad it works, cause that's all that matters. In my new install I did NOT implement a proper star ground implementation but I had clean power and built all power and wiring literally from the ground up.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 4, 2016 12:00:02 GMT -6
I have no idea what a star config is, and google didn't yield results. Would on eof you kind gentlemen offer me a link to read more? My rig is pretty small, and I thought that introducing these power conditioners (Furman PL-8C) would safe guard against these types of issues. My set-up is really very simple TBH so it's hard to understand how the issue isn't the Sweet Ten, since I haven't had this issue previously.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 4, 2016 12:01:03 GMT -6
Transformers induce hum in other transformers. Why would the hum increase when the power is off. Don;t transformers need electricity to output sound?
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 4, 2016 13:25:46 GMT -6
Google "what is star grounding". Plenty to read up on.
But in a simple nutshell (although implementation is ANYTHING but simple) it means ONE path to ground only for each piece of gear. All paths to ground for all gear should be "theoretically" a very similar length. In other words, one should not be 200' and another 6'.
In a practical installation this means (among other things) :
- No shields tied down on both ends of audio cables (telescoping shields) - a well implemented patch bay where shields are treated properly - in many traditional studios - all 3rd pins are lifted on gear with a chassis ground on EACH piece of gear going to a star point (1/4" thick copper plate that is in turn taken to physical ground rod) i.e.: Technical ground. Controversial, but it works like a charm and has since the beginning of studios. - no gear having ground continuity between chassis's. This means wood rack rails or isolating the gear with hum-free's or similar. - all AC outlets star back to the main or sub panel with no daisy chaining in the walls. i.e.: star vs daisy chain. - unbalanced gear i/o's terminated correctly.
Etc., etc..
Another option is balanced power, but that is very expensive. My experiences with balanced power is that it is pure magic, or only helps a bit. Seems to be dependent (just like star grounding) on a lot of other factors in your electrical delivery to your studio gear.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Sept 4, 2016 14:48:24 GMT -6
Transformers induce hum in other transformers. Why would the hum increase when the power is off. Don;t transformers need electricity to output sound? The power transformer in your conditioner creates an electrical field. Any adjacent transformer picks up some amount of that field. Induced hum. In the old days the recommendation was at least 3 feet away from any audio transformer, and transformers were usually much more heavily shielded back then than they are now. Those CAPI and HA output transformers are not themselves shielded. Any casing fully surrounding them is then their shield. That may be an integral part of the 500 module, it may just be the case they are mounted in. Likely not much difference in the shielding qualities of one companies metal enclosure over another. A transformer coupled audio amp can be turned off but connected to a monitored input, and induced hum will be present, no power or amplification required. One possibility. What are you not telling us about how the CAPI and HA were used previously? In a different 500 rack mounted in the same place? Or also new? A lot of equipment will hum MORE when turned off but monitored. I can think of many I have that have no audible hum when powered, yet significant amounts when powered off. This is different from the induced hum I've speculated on.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 5, 2016 13:31:15 GMT -6
Very helpful responses from all! Many thanks! I removed teh Furman PL-8C from the slot above the Sweet Ten chassis (replaced with Furman M-8x2 I had ina closet) and the hum went down considerably. The only way to tell it's present is when turning the monitor output to full volume, which introduces hiss and other faint noises not present when listening at anywhere close to normal volume.
Last couple of questions, I promise!
1) Is ANY hum acceptable? As in the above example where there is still a tiny bit of hum when moitor is cracked to max... 2)Do you guys use rack mounted power conditions or do you keep those on floor as far as is reasonable from transformers, etc? What power strips/conditions do you good people use?
Happy labor day!
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Sept 5, 2016 14:13:11 GMT -6
I've got power conditioners for all different manutfacturers in my racks - ETA, Furman, Juice Goose, and a couple of others. No issues. But I've got my wiring and power issues sorted.
Re:
1. - Yes, degrees of hum ARE acceptable. The amount is up to you, If you put ENOUGH gain on something, you will pull in all kinds of crap. Deciding how much is "OK" is a personal decision. My method of testing : - Bring in a mastered CD track into your DAW. Make sure it exits your D/A conversion @ full scale. Go thru your normal monitoring. Turn up the monitor control room volume until it is so loud you want to scream. Stop the music, raise it just a little more. Is it quiet? if so you're OK. My method when using a console with clients, etc.was to bring a CD player into a stereo channel on the console, hit "0VU", turn the CRM up to WIDE OPEN with power amps attenuated all the way down, and then gradually raise the volume on the power amps until I didn't EVER want them any louder. Is it quiet? OK then, move on. No one ever blew my monitors after that, and properly calibrating the room first kept me from chasing demons that didn't need to be chased.
If you raise your CRM monitoring 50dB above normal listening levels you'll have all KINDS of $#@! coming out your monitors. All of it will most likely never be heard if you have your CRM calibrated properly.
2. As mentioned above, no issue with rack mounted power strips here. You've got something else going on beyond "the normal" I think.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 5, 2016 19:59:52 GMT -6
Thanks, Bill! My feeling is what I now have is within the spectrum of reasonable. I think the hum introduced by the original Furman via the preamp transformers got me spooked and even once I was able to isolate and remove it, I became hyper aware of any and all noise. I think I am going to get on with the business of making music rather than "chasing demons" as you so aptly put it The subject of grounding also has me intrigued as I have NEVER knew much about it other than my Technics turntable which is grounded to a mixer. I just realized that my Neutrik patchbays cam with grounding clips and also have ground tab on the back of them, but I never gave it a second thought. I am now wondering if this is a contributing factor (sounds like every component carrying a signal is). To youtube instructional videos I go!!!!!!!!!! Seriously, thank you all again. I have found this forum to be the most helpful of them all Donation to keep the server lights on coming shortly.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 5, 2016 23:21:06 GMT -6
A lot of equipment will hum MORE when turned off but monitored. I can think of many I have that have no audible hum when powered, yet significant amounts when powered off. This is different from the induced hum I've speculated on. EmRR, this is indeed the case. The hum goes away when the rack/preamps are powered. Obviously for teh purposes of recording that is great and means no hum will be recorded, but still something I'd look to address if possible. Can you speak on the aforementioned scenario?
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Sept 6, 2016 6:32:36 GMT -6
It's a non-issue; we don't record with amps that are turned off. There's no time that would be used. I see it with equipment on the test bench, equipment installed in systems, etc.
|
|
|
Post by mulmany on Sept 6, 2016 21:32:07 GMT -6
One thing I have gotten in the habit of doing is cleaning the paint off around a few of the top/bottom cover screws of any gear. I then test it with a DMM. This makes sure that the whole case is fully grounded to itself. It's solved a few hum issues on its own.
I also have one of those same Furman strips, and stopped using it because of the protection circuits self noise.
|
|
|
Post by chazman on Sept 6, 2016 23:44:58 GMT -6
I also have one of those same Furman strips, and stopped using it because of the protection circuits self noise. Any positive experience with rack mountable power conditioner that doesn't have the same interference issues?
|
|