|
Post by geoff738 on Oct 21, 2024 11:11:13 GMT -6
Ok. On a train. Three hours in, five to six more to go. Bored, despite the lovely fall foliage out the window.
Anyhow. Serial compression. There’s the 1176/La2a for vocals combo. Anybody like tracking with these and if so is there an order you prefer?
Any other applications and or other compressors you like to use in series?
Cheers, Geoff
|
|
|
Post by bossanova on Oct 21, 2024 11:26:33 GMT -6
1176-A/Blue, 12:1, 6 attack, 7 release, 5 db GR on peaks.
La2a - needle just barely moving, 2-3 GR max.
UAD for both. I don’t know about tracking but that’s what I’ve used for mixing sung vocals for a while. Add additional compression, clip gain, and/or riding to taste.
|
|
|
Post by geoff738 on Oct 21, 2024 11:37:50 GMT -6
I usually track vocals through the Daking Fet pulling about 5 dbs. I also clip gain and then I can compress again but pretty lightly. I have an 1176 and 2a clones, Warm and Behringer respectively. And I have not tried using them in series. I should try it out but I have only tried it itb. Not sure I loved what it was doing.
Cheers, Geoff
|
|
|
Post by notneeson on Oct 21, 2024 11:38:19 GMT -6
Ok. On a train. Three hours in, five to six more to go. Bored, despite the lovely fall foliage out the window. Anyhow. Serial compression. There’s the 1176/La2a for vocals combo. Anybody like tracking with these and if so is there an order you prefer? Any other applications and or other compressors you like to use in series? Cheers, Geoff I like it for tracking others, I don’t like it for recording myself, too much risk and not enough reward if I screw it up.
|
|
|
Post by svart on Oct 21, 2024 11:38:26 GMT -6
Ok. On a train. Three hours in, five to six more to go. Bored, despite the lovely fall foliage out the window. Anyhow. Serial compression. There’s the 1176/La2a for vocals combo. Anybody like tracking with these and if so is there an order you prefer? Any other applications and or other compressors you like to use in series? Cheers, Geoff I used to, but I'm not sure if I ever made it work well. It was 1176 first to grab transients. Now I'm just 1176 on vocals and I think it works a lot better than the two together. It could have been a skill issue though..
|
|
|
Post by drumsound on Oct 21, 2024 11:42:51 GMT -6
I had good luck recently with the faster, more aggressive compressor second. I was using a Drawmer '69 as basic leveling 2-4 DB medium attack (2) and medium program dependant release(5). That went into a Purple Action grabbing things not tamed but the '69. Fast attack and release. I don't remember the ratio, but it was probably 12:1.
This was vocal tracking, btw
|
|
|
Post by smashlord on Oct 21, 2024 12:46:18 GMT -6
As always, depends on the application. Sometimes it's LA-2A> 1176, other times its 1176, LA-2A or 1175/LA-3A or 1176/1176.
Sometimes the order of 1176 first or second is determined by how obvious I want the 1176s artifacts to be.... if the goal is audible pumping for aggressive or energy, I'd err on the side of having the 1176 second in the chain. If I want the 1176 for tone and grit but maybe not hearing its breathing effects as much, an LA-3A after it can help hide them a bit with the sympathetic release.
Lately, I have been loving tracking with one channel of a 670 because you can smack it 10+ dB and not hear it. The vocal just gets thicker and smoother. With the vocal then controlled, you can punish the 1176 afterwards for vibe and keep it in its sweet spot.
|
|
|
Post by geoff738 on Oct 21, 2024 13:02:49 GMT -6
I feel the same about the Vcomp. If the meter is to be believed it can be taking 10+ dbs off easily and these old ears can’t hear the compression. I have a Cranesong Trakker that can compress quite a bit and stay pretty darn transparent.
Cheers, Geoff
|
|
|
Post by basspro on Oct 21, 2024 13:04:12 GMT -6
For a more dynamic vocal, I usually go Audioscape 76D set pretty fast on 4:1 taking off 5-7 dB on Peaks to an Acme Opticom 500 on Normal speed taking off 2-3 dB constantly. Have gotten some very finished sounding vocals this way. Have also ruined otherwise great performances, so if it's not immediately apparent that it's working, I'll usually remove the Acme and just have the 76D set slower and working a little harder.
|
|
|
Post by copperx on Oct 21, 2024 14:38:57 GMT -6
For those using serial compression, can you specify if the serial compression is happening during tracking or half during tracking then the other half during mixdown?
|
|
|
Post by Dan on Oct 21, 2024 14:54:30 GMT -6
i just use a more program dependent compressor and save on distortion. one that can speed up on transients. oxford dynamics, kotelnikov, molot, psp impressor, weiss ds1 or renaissance compressor ran up into the the limiter. hardware, you can use aphex 661, crane song, drawmer 241/251, elysia, tube tech clb1 if you set them correctly.
dbx 160 -> 1176 is a classic. overeasy button is smoother.
|
|
|
Post by mcirish on Oct 21, 2024 14:55:49 GMT -6
I have a couple 1176 and LA2A hardware (UA and AS). Even with having them, I find that I don't use them both during tracking. Rock songs, it's usually the 1176 and ballads would be the LA2A. I just have a fear of too much compression on the way in. So, a single compressor on the way in but I do use three more on a vocal ITB, in series. None of them doing too much.
|
|
|
Post by drumsound on Oct 21, 2024 15:03:19 GMT -6
For those using serial compression, can you specify if the serial compression is happening during tracking or half during tracking then the other half during mixdown? I was referencing hardware in tracking. I don't always do it, but it's worked recently. I may still be compressing during mixing, sometimes, but not usually, even serial compression AGAIN...
|
|
|
Post by christophert on Oct 21, 2024 16:18:12 GMT -6
After using LA2A's, 1176's, Sta Levels, over decades, these days I track with a BG2 tube comp, because it can compress a lot without any artifacts. Now I have no desire to track with an 1176 or LA2a on vocals. I never really liked the 1176 to track vocals with. Sta Level is generally incredible, but not great on fast stuff.
Mix time I usually use MJUC / Arbiter / and a final invisible comp like PSP Flare or Koletenov, and even another super fast compressor / clipper at the front of the chain if it is for Rap - or some rock singers.
In the past I rarely had two compressors in a chain when mixing vocals - these days I can have up to 4 comps, as we have so many great compression tools at our disposal. Each comp does a different job, and has a different response and sound.
|
|
|
Post by geoff738 on Oct 21, 2024 17:14:51 GMT -6
After using LA2A's, 1176's, Sta Levels, over decades, these days I track with a BG2 tube comp, because it can compress a lot without any artifacts. Now I have no desire to track with an 1176 or LA2a on vocals. I never really liked the 1176 to track vocals with. Sta Level is generally incredible, but not great on fast stuff. Mix time I usually use MJUC / Arbiter / and a final invisible comp like PSP Flare or Koletenov, and even another super fast compressor / clipper at the front of the chain if it is for Rap - or some rock singers. In the past I rarely had two compressors in a chain when mixing vocals - these days I can have up to 4 comps, as we have so many great compression tools at our disposal. Each comp does a different job, and has a different response and sound. Ok, 4 comps? All in a row? Which ones and how hard are you hitting each one? This reminds me I did pick up Koletnikov recently but haven’t really dug in to see what it can do. I need to do that. Cheers, Geoff
|
|
|
Post by smashlord on Oct 21, 2024 22:14:22 GMT -6
For those using serial compression, can you specify if the serial compression is happening during tracking or half during tracking then the other half during mixdown? Could be both. Couple, two, tree on the way in and another on the back end. Some vocals are rambunctious little fellas a need a few smacks to keep em in line.
|
|
|
Post by christophert on Oct 22, 2024 1:19:02 GMT -6
After using LA2A's, 1176's, Sta Levels, over decades, these days I track with a BG2 tube comp, because it can compress a lot without any artifacts. Now I have no desire to track with an 1176 or LA2a on vocals. I never really liked the 1176 to track vocals with. Sta Level is generally incredible, but not great on fast stuff. Mix time I usually use MJUC / Arbiter / and a final invisible comp like PSP Flare or Koletenov, and even another super fast compressor / clipper at the front of the chain if it is for Rap - or some rock singers. In the past I rarely had two compressors in a chain when mixing vocals - these days I can have up to 4 comps, as we have so many great compression tools at our disposal. Each comp does a different job, and has a different response and sound. Ok, 4 comps? All in a row? Which ones and how hard are you hitting each one? This reminds me I did pick up Koletnikov recently but haven’t really dug in to see what it can do. I need to do that. Cheers, Geoff When using a few comps you can get compression artifacts to be more transparent, as opposed to trying to do it all with one or two.
Hardly ever 4 comps in a row, usually EQ is inserted somewhere. But when I do, one comp is giving me a healthy amount of slow attack fast release tube behavior (MJUC), another may be addressing the odd spiky word and it's job is to do very little but interact with fast moments (Koletenov - Molot) Another compresses HF and esses (Arbiter) Sometimes I also use Arbiter or Oxford dynamic EQ to compress only low vocal mids. The last comp is just 2:1 gentle compression, but I want it to have a sound - more definition and clarity. PSP Flare as the final compressor has lately become a bit of a game changer for me.
Obviously this is all dependent on the music - sometimes I only use compression when I track, and automation when mixing.
|
|
|
Post by frans on Oct 22, 2024 1:44:37 GMT -6
I always ride the gain when tracking vocals - does that count as one stage of "compression"? After that it goes to the JLM opto which is so smooth i sometimes don't notice it's already doing something. In the mix i do gain automation according to what else is happening in the song at the same time and sometimes another layer of compression...sometimes not. And i still like the stock logic compressor in "boring" mode (no emulation). There's also that Altec varimu clone a friend built and i have to use that more for vocals. And sometimes it's the Valvotronics GainRyder which is even smoother and stealthier than the JLM so i often have to look at the rack "is it doing anything at all?".
If the vocal screams "Purple meeee!!!" i will throw on the Purple action (in tracking) for that nicely aggressive layer of what it does so well.
|
|
|
Post by thehightenor on Oct 22, 2024 1:52:39 GMT -6
I even use it on my stereo mix bus. Cubase > HEDD 92 > RMS755 (VCA) > Thermionic Phoenix MP (vari mu) The VCA is set to std kinda attack release for an ssl style VCA just to give some micro dynamics and envelope to the rhythm of the track and then the Phoenix gives the track size, depth and gloss. So serial comp definitely works for me on the stereo mix bus. On mixing I tend to prefer parallels to serial but occasionally I do dig the 1176 > 2A or STA - usually FET before Opto. Personally, with 24 bit audio and quality of converters here in 2024 I wouldn’t track with a 76 - there’s just no need to paint yourself into any corners and a FET can get you to a negative place faster than you can say “1176”
|
|
|
Post by Dan on Oct 22, 2024 7:48:55 GMT -6
I even use it on my stereo mix bus. Cubase > HEDD 92 > RMS755 (VCA) > Thermionic Phoenix MP (vari mu) The VCA is set to std kinda attack release for an ssl style VCA just to give some micro dynamics and envelope to the rhythm of the track and then the Phoenix gives the track size, depth and gloss. So serial comp definitely works for me on the stereo mix bus. On mixing I tend to prefer parallels to serial but occasionally I do dig the 1176 > 2A or STA - usually FET before Opto. Personally, with 24 bit audio and quality of converters here in 2024 I wouldn’t track with a 76 - there’s just no need to paint yourself into any corners and a FET can get you to a negative place faster than you can say “1176” Depends on the FET. An 1176 has fast attack but doesn’t release that fast no matter what the manual says because it has an auto release that’s always on to prevent the typical “slam the needle and break the meter” dumb ass from getting themselves into a situation they cannot automate or fader ride their way out of. It holds the audio down on brief peaks if the meter is moving at all making it not a great peak limiter. The VU meter sucks. You pretty much want it not moving hardly at all on an 1176 and fastest release. A spectrasonics (spectra 1964) complimiter, the limiter part is super fast and there’s a light to see if it’s active. Of course you can easily butcher a take into distortion with one but you can smash peaks quickly and level the audio somewhat. A daking compressor is even slower than an 1176. Great general compressor, especially on auto, not a great peak limiter for brief peaks. Much harder to ruin your audio with it than with an 1176, complimiter, or a distressor. More program dependent compressors like faster, more consistent optical compressors (only cl1b lets you control The automatic response to fit it to the audio but how do you track with that? A maselec or unmodded la4 over compressing can ruin the audio too), advanced vca and pwm auto comps, or modern digital compressors with multiple detectors do not have this and can lock a vocal in place used correctly.
|
|
|
Post by peterr on Oct 22, 2024 16:19:54 GMT -6
1176-A/Blue, 12:1, 6 attack, 7 release, 5 db GR on peaks. La2a - needle just barely moving, 2-3 GR max. UAD for both. I don’t know about tracking but that’s what I’ve used for mixing sung vocals for a while. Add additional compression, clip gain, and/or riding to taste. I track vocals with hardware Purple MC76 into AS Opto with almost identical settings.
|
|
|
Post by Bat Lanyard on Oct 22, 2024 21:12:24 GMT -6
Lately going RS660 -> RS660, pretty strong then super gentle. My Bluey is suddenly super noisy or would try that (gotta figure that noise out).
We don't track with compression. I need options and honestly not expert enough to commit to it on the way in.
|
|
|
Post by vvvooojjj on Oct 23, 2024 1:17:34 GMT -6
While mixing yesterday I ran vocals into CL1B -> LA3. Some volume automation before the chain not to make CL1B pump. And later when tracking vocals into another project Chandler Opto into Empirical Pump.
|
|