|
Post by gwlee7 on Feb 15, 2023 8:15:34 GMT -6
And when I moved out of the UA platform, I sold my satellite to one person, traded my Twin in, and "gifted" all the plugins to another in exchange for ongoing help on a multi-song project.
|
|
|
Post by ragan on Feb 15, 2023 8:53:28 GMT -6
This would sting if I was still in UAD land. Kinda inevitable though I think. Their DSP is way underpowered and their LOL prices weren't going to be sustainable. Being outside the UAD ecosystem, this is kinda enticing. There are one or two plugs (EMT 140 and 250, Dimension D) that I still miss. At reasonable prices for native plugs, I'd consider picking them up.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 8:57:50 GMT -6
But wait till they are uadx to run native or buy on price and wait?
|
|
|
Post by tkaitkai on Feb 15, 2023 9:25:14 GMT -6
I think this is rubbing people the wrong way because UA could have just done this the whole goddamn time.
Like, it's been a major complaint for years that you couldn't just buy the plugins you want and run them Native. So if you really wanted to get into UAD, you HAD to buy DSP (super expensive), AND you had to buy the plugins themselves (also expensive), AND you were artificially limited to a certain number of plugin instances.
People loved the plugins enough to put up with the hassle, and the whole thing was often justified on the basis that UAD plugs are so meticulously coded to model the real deal that they're insanely resource-hungry, thus making DSP a necessity.
Don't get me wrong — it's a great system, and it clearly has benefits, but I think a lot of people are grouchy because buying DSP was never their first choice to begin with, and if given the option, they would've just bought a few Native plugs and left it at that.
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 16,107
|
Post by ericn on Feb 15, 2023 9:38:42 GMT -6
I think this is rubbing people the wrong way because UA could have just done this the whole goddamn time. Like, it's been a major complaint for years that you couldn't just buy the plugins you want and run them Native. So if you really wanted to get into UAD, you HAD to buy DSP (super expensive), AND you had to buy the plugins themselves (also expensive), AND you were artificially limited to a certain number of plugin instances. People loved the plugins enough to put up with the hassle, and the whole thing was often justified on the basis that UAD plugs are so meticulously coded to model the real deal that they're insanely resource-hungry, thus making DSP a necessity. Don't get me wrong — it's a great system, and it clearly has benefits, but I think a lot of people are grouchy because buying DSP was never their first choice to begin with, and if given the option, they would've just bought a few Native plugs and left it at that. The biggest UAD DSP complaint was the total expense and that the latency was never as low as PT TDM.
|
|
|
Post by drsax on Feb 15, 2023 10:11:53 GMT -6
Remember the days when there were no plugins? Man, now that was expensive. One day in a reputable studio was 2k+ plus several hundred dollars for the cost of tape.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 10:17:07 GMT -6
@tkai
That’s my basic point, and its irksome for ua to play dumb as it completely undermines its established plug in business model that we all paid big bucks to support and as it is doing this, it offers new, least invested clients, the best deal ever and wanted to charge invested clients more for less plugs?
Why not just send us the new UA merch t Dumb, Dumber and Dumbest with a big arrow pointing up ?
|
|
|
Post by drsax on Feb 15, 2023 10:20:58 GMT -6
P.S. I love you guys and I’ve spent a ton of time on this forum over the years. I’ve been on much less in the last year or so, as I find many threads have become more like this one. A lot of talented cats on here, and really great guys, and I know times are tough, especially for musicians, but man, we are completely and utterly spoiled with the tools that are available to us for the price they’re available for. As technology increases, prices are going to keep dropping. That’s just the nature of it all. As computer processors have become more powerful, the switch to native was inevitable. In fact, most people have been begging for it for well over a decade now from UA and here it is. I guess my perspective isn’t in alignment with majority. Peace and blessings fellas - Darren
|
|
|
Post by drumsound on Feb 15, 2023 10:28:41 GMT -6
I’m seeing this in such a different light I guess? The money I’ve made from using the UAD plugins that I really like and use on every mix / project have more than paid for themselves over and over again. So for me - I’ve gotten my value out Of what I paid for. Quite a bit of value actually. Now, add in the fact that I can just buy some bundles, run plugs off my computer processor and not have to worry about running out of dsp or purchasing a satellite? Oh wait and I can still use the dsp stuff I already have in case my computer hiccups? Killer! Keep my workflow and remove a hassle, score a write off all in the same process? Sign me up. My mindset may also be slightly different as I NEVER look at a piece of software or computer hardware as something that I’ll ever see a return on in the form of a second hand sale. Guitars, drum kits, cymbals, any other instrument, compressors, eq’s? Hell yeah that’s written in as part of the investment. But not software. That money is gone as far as I’m concerned - research and demo before you buy. Sometimes it’s a gem and sometimes you get burnt. I got a pint of haagen das last week for 7 bucks. Enjoyed the hell out of it. That stuff is 2 for $8 this week. Am I pissed? I’ll let you know in a half hour when I finish all this ice cream. This is totally on point. Software and plugins (and everything we buy really) are tools to get the job done. Unless you're buying vintage mics, and certain outboard, the value of resale shouldn't be the focus. Working and getting the best possible results are where it's at. You can resell software licenses not Waves plugins or Sonnox Oxford Inflator on KVR pretty easily. But UA forces you to sell all or none, not individual licenses. I do wish you could sell, or even trade UA plugins. I bought gwlee's system, and there are guitar amps I don't really need. But there might be someone who would use them. It's OK, I'll live. And when I moved out of the UA platform, I sold my satellite to one person, traded my Twin in, and "gifted" all the plugins to another in exchange for ongoing help on a multi-song project. And its a trade I'm still happy we made! P.S. I love you guys and I’ve spent a ton of time on this forum over the years. I’ve been on much less in the last year or so, as I find many threads have become more like this one. A lot of talented cats on here, and really great guys, and I know times are tough, especially for musicians, but man, we are completely and utterly spoiled with the tools that are available to us for the price they’re available for. As technology increases, prices are going to keep dropping. That’s just the nature of it all. As computer processors have become more powerful, the switch to native was inevitable. In fact, most people have been begging for it for well over a decade now from UA and here it is. I guess my perspective isn’t in alignment with majority. Peace and blessings fellas - Darren 100%
|
|
|
Post by Martin John Butler on Feb 15, 2023 10:29:37 GMT -6
I think tkaitkai just said it best. That IS what's been bugging us for a long time.
Running out of DSP and needing a $1,000 satellite was just too much to ask when similar plug-ins were available native from other companies. Perhaps early on it made more sense. Not enough DSP was making productions difficult back in 2012-2015.
I've used UAD's ATR-102 on everything I've done since 2012. I've found nothing to compare in overall effect on the whole mix. I could do an entire album with just that and be happy. It should have been called the waybetternow plug.
The EMT-140 nails it for acoustic guitars. I also used the Ocean Way plug-in as a room sound, but quite sparingly. The Massive Passive comes in handy on rare occasions.
The Pultec's, 1176's and LA2A's are as good as anything else, but not in any way a wow factor. The dozen or so other plug-ins I have I rarely use anymore. So, for me, the only plug-in of UAD I truly need for it to be my sound is the ATR-102. The Ocean Way, EMT-140, LA2'a, 1176, Ocean Way could all go away tomorrow and I'd have at least 4 or 5 replacements that are useable.
The thing is, they've served me well as I familiarized myself with digital production since 2012. (I had previously retired from music for 15 years due to illness). The console interface was intuitive enough that I was able to acclimate easier. It's still a great tool. I haven't tried Luna. I see no reason to learn a new DAW that is still way behind Logic when it comes to editing features I absolutely must have for mixing. Maybe somewhere down the road I'll try it, probably not. It seemed like another money grab to lock me into buying yet more UAD plug-ins.
So, if UAD makes the ATR-102 available native, I could painlessly move away from their ecosystem. But right now, the music business pays me 10% of what I made in the 1980's, so I'm not able to make upgrades I desire anymore. I'll have to stick with my Apollo for a while, so I'm really glad I have the Black Lion Audio full mod. That has made a huge difference. The UAD converters always bugged me. Since it's basically a computer with a couple of preamps, the Apollo I have may become a big paper weight going forward. But it will have served me well.
All UAD really had to do to make their customers happy and potentially become lifetime customers was make the plug-ins less expensive and allow some form of exchange or sale. It seems to me, UAD's stockholders value short term profit over long term sustainability, and that has caused their loyal customers lots of frustration. Enough to wish you could tell them to go fuck themselves in some instances.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 10:33:44 GMT -6
I am not arguing against change, but for reciprocity.
Since UA created this two tiered client group, favouring the least invested client, right in front of your face, to be reciprocal all it had to do, was see which clients had already paid $1200+ on plugs and then deposit the remaining authorizations to complete U11 into their accounts.
Simple and easily doable, but no.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 10:49:21 GMT -6
drumsound ah, forgive me, let’s use your situation as a test case: ah, you bought your plugs and satellite second hand: right? So, now that you don’t need the dsp and can buy bundles of native plugs at about 25% of retail, would you be prepared to pay the same price for your used gear or would you just buy native plugs, if they were cheaper ? We’d all buy the cheaper plugs, unless the card and second hand plugs were heavily discounted or unless, some key plugs you wanted were included? Other than a few plugs with licensing issues preventing UA from selling natively(neve), it would seem all UA plugs will go native. a new octo is still $1200 plus tax, for a few hundred more you can buy a screaming m2 pro with way more processing speed and capacity, why buy a new octo now?
|
|
|
Post by the other mark williams on Feb 15, 2023 11:02:33 GMT -6
I imagine that I’m one of the types of person at whom this move is targeted: I’m doing this professionally, but I’ve literally never used a UAD plugin, because I’ve never wanted to buy their DSP or interfaces. I’ve certainly considered it many times over the years, but I’ve always found good sounding native plugins to do what I need. Honestly, the growth of Luna is one of the things that’s been most interesting to observe as an outsider these past couple years.
Anyway, now that at least some of these plugins are available to me, i find myself curious: How is the LA2A “bundle”? How about the 1176 “bundle”? I have other things that I use for those now, obviously, but I wonder what the UAD offerings are actually like in comparison.
|
|
|
Post by jaba on Feb 15, 2023 11:07:38 GMT -6
Doesn't a lot of technology get cheaper over time?
Computers, VCRs, CD players, etc etc all started out crazy expensive and if you wanted them in your life early you could, but you paid for it. Wait a few years/decades and things get generally cheaper, even the quality stuff. You didn't get to enjoy them for a long time but you saved $$.
I do understand the frustration though. It's natural. But in the end it's a business doing business to stay in business. No surprise there.
|
|
ericn
Temp
Balance Engineer
Posts: 16,107
|
Post by ericn on Feb 15, 2023 11:14:19 GMT -6
I imagine that I’m one of the types of person at whom this move is targeted: I’m doing this professionally, but I’ve literally never used a UAD plugin, because I’ve never wanted to buy their DSP or interfaces. I’ve certainly considered it many times over the years, but I’ve always found good sounding native plugins to do what I need. Honestly, the growth of Luna is one of the things that’s been most interesting to observe as an outsider these past couple years. Anyway, now that at least some of these plugins are available to me, i find myself curious: How is the LA2A “bundle”? How about the 1176 “bundle”? I have other things that I use for those now, obviously, but I wonder what the UAD offerings are actually like in comparison. Mark I don’t think this is aimed at you, I think this is aimed at the guy who in the past bought all those little interfaces you see used on GC.com. I think as Luna grows we just might see the 3rd act of UAD DSP.
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 11:15:07 GMT -6
I imagine that I’m one of the types of person at whom this move is targeted: I’m doing this professionally, but I’ve literally never used a UAD plugin, because I’ve never wanted to buy their DSP or interfaces. I’ve certainly considered it many times over the years, but I’ve always found good sounding native plugins to do what I need. Honestly, the growth of Luna is one of the things that’s been most interesting to observe as an outsider these past couple years. Anyway, now that at least some of these plugins are available to me, i find myself curious: How is the LA2A “bundle”? How about the 1176 “bundle”? I have other things that I use for those now, obviously, but I wonder what the UAD offerings are actually like in comparison. Try the demo!
|
|
|
Post by kcatthedog on Feb 15, 2023 11:16:29 GMT -6
I imagine that I’m one of the types of person at whom this move is targeted: I’m doing this professionally, but I’ve literally never used a UAD plugin, because I’ve never wanted to buy their DSP or interfaces. I’ve certainly considered it many times over the years, but I’ve always found good sounding native plugins to do what I need. Honestly, the growth of Luna is one of the things that’s been most interesting to observe as an outsider these past couple years. Anyway, now that at least some of these plugins are available to me, i find myself curious: How is the LA2A “bundle”? How about the 1176 “bundle”? I have other things that I use for those now, obviously, but I wonder what the UAD offerings are actually like in comparison. Try the demo! New ua user famous last words
|
|
|
Post by drumrec on Feb 15, 2023 11:17:15 GMT -6
I jumped on the UAD train day 1 with a UAD-1 card and over the years have bought almost every single plug and have 4 Apollo X interfaces. In other words, invested a fortune in the UA eco system. This development with the Native plugin and the powerful computers, it was inevitable for UA not to go that way. I think jeremygillespie has wise words in what he says and agree 110%. A small sidenote for those who work in Luna, there has been a new update of Luna to 1.4 and there are really smart solutions for Apollo/Luna users between native vs DSP plugin when mixing and recording. Worth checking out.
|
|
|
Post by jeremygillespie on Feb 15, 2023 11:17:16 GMT -6
I am not arguing against change, but for reciprocity. Since UA created this two tiered client group, favouring the least invested client, right in front of your face, to be reciprocal all it had to do, was see which clients had already paid $1200+ on plugs and then deposit the remaining authorizations to complete U11 into their accounts. Simple and easily doable, but no. But…. Nobody is saying to stop using your dsp plugins. They are still there, can still be used. Does anybody want to put an actual quantifiable number on the money they’ve lost because UA decided to give people what they’ve been asking for the last what… 10 years? As far as I understand it, did they not have to re-code the plugins to run natively? Are they just supposed to eat that? They are sort of in a damned if you do damned if you don’t situation. Not to mention that I don’t think anybody here has paid actual full price for their plugins in years. There is always a coupon or a bundle that somebody posts up here. Again, I do understand the frustration, but let’s take a beat here and see the full picture. A massive company can’t just put r&d into porting their plugs over and then give them away to everybody that already owns the old (and still very much so usable) versions.
|
|
|
Post by Quint on Feb 15, 2023 11:21:23 GMT -6
I am not arguing against change, but for reciprocity. Since UA created this two tiered client group, favouring the least invested client, right in front of your face, to be reciprocal all it had to do, was see which clients had already paid $1200+ on plugs and then deposit the remaining authorizations to complete U11 into their accounts. Simple and easily doable, but no. But…. Nobody is saying to stop using your dsp plugins. They are still there, can still be used. Does anybody want to put an actual quantifiable number on the money they’ve lost because UA decided to give people what they’ve been asking for the last what… 10 years? As far as I understand it, did they not have to re-code the plugins to run natively? Are they just supposed to eat that? They are sort of in a damned if you do damned if you don’t situation. Not to mention that I don’t think anybody here has paid actual full price for their plugins in years. There is always a coupon or a bundle that somebody posts up here. Exactly. That's why I'm having a hard time with some of the complaints.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 15, 2023 11:27:46 GMT -6
Remember the days when there were no plugins? Man, now that was expensive. One day in a reputable studio was 2k+ plus several hundred dollars for the cost of tape. Now people think they can your job because they can buy a couple pieces to a lot of recording hardware if they have a job. If they’re a dentist or programmer, they can buy an entire studio. And their productions still sound awful vs run of the mill ones from decade ago. So do today’s big budget productions.
|
|
|
Post by christopher on Feb 15, 2023 11:41:19 GMT -6
Why are people upset? Because for decades there was excuses why they couldn’t do it. And everyone knew the real excuse was greed. It costs absolutely nothing to manufacture a new software instance: it’s a money printer. Software is probably cheaper to deliver and store than printing actual cash.
I have no actual numbers and I’m pulling this out of thin air, but that’s how easy it is to see:
Imagine if every guitarist wants a UA LUNA recorder. Say hundred million of potential buyers worldwide. If you charge each one $1 that’s a $100million TAM (total addressable market) to chase. At just $1
But if you charge 0.1% of those who actually do pro recording $10,000 each customer, you milk that target market until it dries up.. thats a potential 100,000 user TAM: $1 billion TAM
So if you just see the TAM, the real money maker is in keeping prices low and access high-
The problem is GREED: nobody is willing to go so low in price that they dominate TAM. Waves seems like they might be figuring it out. $29 is still waaaaaaaaaaaay high for what they actually deliver, =money printing.
Now, there’s no reason to go to $1 and stop… they could do like others.. $30 etc, upgrade etc.
UAD has the top rep, they will be ok
People like me will always be upset they chose to milk the pro’s wallets instead of spread it to the masses, which would have made them more money anyway!
|
|
|
Post by ab101 on Feb 15, 2023 11:43:51 GMT -6
We live in a fairly polarized world where things seem to go to extremes. For me, I am not really complaining, but I am curious as to why UAD is doing this now in light of (or in conjunction with) the recent layoffs. Does this foretell financial stability for UAD in the future or is this a sign of hard times for UAD and a band-aid approach to raise immediate cash? I think this is fair to ask. It is not like the recent times have exhibited enormous stability.
And while musician/recording folks are experiencing the great benefits of lower priced plugs, the CD market has been gutted a lot (at least for me), and I was able to do better financially with CDs than digital downloads. And stealing music has not helped. And the pandemic did not help, especially as I am on the "old" side and this made it difficult to record, rehearse and play out with fellow band members.
I think there are many people who are in "post-pandemic" adjustment mode which includes some irritability. And then there is the supply chain issues and uncertainty about the economy. (And I have not even mentioned that a country with the most nukes is at war right now and we do not know what they will do if they continue to lose.) Uncertainty and irritability may go together. I think it is healthy to express one's concerns.
And yet with all this, I refuse to give up, I refuse to wallow in negativity. This involves working on the most important programming - my own brain and thinking.
The important thing for me is that this is a great forum and people here are really respectful regardless of viewpoints, something that I think this world desperately needs at this point in time. Every small provision of this respect helps.
I am reminded of an ancient proverb: A wise person learns from everyone. I look forward to more of the wonderful diverse voices here.
|
|
|
Post by christopher on Feb 15, 2023 12:08:47 GMT -6
If I were CEO, it’s simple, this is how I’d thank my customers:
For every dollar spent in the past, you access to get “X amount” of pre-IPO shares. As a legacy customer thank you for helping support UA to become the worldwide name in audio.
Then I’d develop the plan for the eventual move into mainstream DSP of all types. See if I could spin-off UA analog into its own LLC so it’s protected from the digital side,… and maybe it has some lower risk investment into digital so it benefits when digital side does good.
Then keep this guitar center TAM thing going, start to work on contract DSP for big players ESPN? FOX Sports? Google? Etc. get the logo seen.
After a few years, take the digital side public and grow from there.
It would take a lot of lawyers.. but it seems fair to me LOL
|
|
|
Post by gravesnumber9 on Feb 15, 2023 12:15:02 GMT -6
I imagine that I’m one of the types of person at whom this move is targeted: I’m doing this professionally, but I’ve literally never used a UAD plugin, because I’ve never wanted to buy their DSP or interfaces. I’ve certainly considered it many times over the years, but I’ve always found good sounding native plugins to do what I need. Honestly, the growth of Luna is one of the things that’s been most interesting to observe as an outsider these past couple years. Anyway, now that at least some of these plugins are available to me, i find myself curious: How is the LA2A “bundle”? How about the 1176 “bundle”? I have other things that I use for those now, obviously, but I wonder what the UAD offerings are actually like in comparison. Try the demo! The old timey LA-2 in that bundle is pretty fun I think. It really sounds... well, like a compressor/limiter invented before anyone had any idea of how to control the action. It's not subtle, definitely a "color" tool to put it mildly. And I disagree with ericn on this one. At least partially. I agree that this is a down-market move, but it's also surely a move towards folks that were never going to buy UA hardware and so have not touched the plugs. There are plenty of pros who couldn't find a use for an x8 or whatever and didn't see the sense in buying a Satellite Dongle. I'm sure UA is hoping they will sell some bundles to those studios and they probably will if I had to bet.
|
|