|
Post by rob61 on Nov 25, 2022 8:00:39 GMT -6
I need a pair of drum overheads for a couple heavy cymbal bashers. They are looking for a lower cost solution. So far, I think the Roswell Mini K47 matched pair at 850 seems to be a good fit. Budget can go higher, but probably under 2000. Any suggestions from personal experience? They are looking to minimize harshness from all the cymbals.
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Nov 25, 2022 8:15:36 GMT -6
Ribbon mics would be the best move. Dunno what the budget is but you can find m160s for cheap with exchange rates as they are. If those are out of budget maybe try those SE X1Rs? Haven’t heard them but I seem to remember folks here digging them
Edit: I should note I almost exclusively record cymbal bashers and I am one myself
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Nov 25, 2022 8:18:48 GMT -6
Just looked up those mini k47s. You really can buy m160s for not much more right now
|
|
|
Post by rob61 on Nov 25, 2022 8:19:30 GMT -6
Ribbon mics would be the best move. Dunno what the budget is but you can find m160s for cheap with exchange rates as they are. If those are out of budget maybe try those SE X1Rs? Haven’t heard them but I seem to remember folks here digging them That was my thought too, but it is an institutional setting with different drummers going in and out of a drum cage and I was thinking a ribbon might be too fragile. I thought staying with a large diaphram less bright condenser might be a better/safer choice. But I like your idea of ribbons.
|
|
|
Post by phdamage on Nov 25, 2022 8:23:02 GMT -6
Ribbon mics would be the best move. Dunno what the budget is but you can find m160s for cheap with exchange rates as they are. If those are out of budget maybe try those SE X1Rs? Haven’t heard them but I seem to remember folks here digging them That was my thought too, but it is an institutional setting with different drummers going in and out of a drum cage and I was thinking a ribbon might be too fragile. I thought staying with a large diaphram less bright condenser might be a better/safer choice. But I like your idea of ribbons. I have a ton of ribbon mics and have for years. The only ones that have needed new ribbons here and there are the ones who see guitar amp duty. Maybe others will chime in, but unless dudes are hitting them with their sticks, you should be good. Also, ribbons are great on OH even for non cymbal bashers. You could pair a single ribbon with an XY or spaced pair of condensers and lean on the ribbon more or less, depending on the drummer.
|
|
|
Post by rob61 on Nov 25, 2022 9:20:58 GMT -6
They have a very constrained iso booth for drums not much bigger than the drumset with low ceiling. While all mics will be compromised in such a small space, I'm wondering how the M160 would handle it.
|
|
|
Post by tkaitkai on Nov 25, 2022 9:34:28 GMT -6
Ribbon mics would be the best move. Dunno what the budget is but you can find m160s for cheap with exchange rates as they are. If those are out of budget maybe try those SE X1Rs? Haven’t heard them but I seem to remember folks here digging them Edit: I should note I almost exclusively record cymbal bashers and I am one myself This was my first thought, too. A pair of Fatheads would be another great choice.
|
|
|
Post by drumsound on Nov 25, 2022 9:56:23 GMT -6
Ribbon mics would be the best move. Dunno what the budget is but you can find m160s for cheap with exchange rates as they are. If those are out of budget maybe try those SE X1Rs? Haven’t heard them but I seem to remember folks here digging them That was my thought too, but it is an institutional setting with different drummers going in and out of a drum cage and I was thinking a ribbon might be too fragile. I thought staying with a large diaphram less bright condenser might be a better/safer choice. But I like your idea of ribbons. SPL is the worry with ribbons and as overheads, they won't be getting huge blasts of air. No reason to worry.
|
|
|
Post by drbill on Nov 25, 2022 10:06:08 GMT -6
Ribbons were my first thought as well. Either Coles 4038's, or the AL95 Samar's which you can get for $350-ish this weekend. They sound very similar to the 4038's. There's a comparison video floating around. Also, as previously mentioned, the Beyer 160's would be an excellent choice. Robust and NOT fig 8 - but still ribbony. The low ceiling could be a problem with the fig8 mics. I'd have to try to know for sure, but that could nix some of the ribbons. That said, I'd probably go Samar first, and 160 second if I was gambling without trying.
|
|
|
Post by dok on Nov 25, 2022 11:08:17 GMT -6
m160s are really the perfect application for this. and after hearing those Samars compared to the Coles I'd be giving them serious consideration if I didn't already have the m160s.
|
|
|
Post by svart on Nov 25, 2022 11:55:32 GMT -6
Never had any issue with oktava mk012s. The pad gets screwed in between the capsule and the amp.
|
|
|
Post by mcirish on Nov 25, 2022 13:14:55 GMT -6
Never had any issue with oktava mk012s. The pad gets screwed in between the capsule and the amp. I'm a fan of the MK-012 but they might be a little too present for a cymbal basher.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Nov 25, 2022 14:10:44 GMT -6
I usually have M160/M130 in MS in my 7'6" room. I have 3 stereo Samar options, vintage RCA's, Fatheads, and the Beyers are just usually the thing that works best. I bought my Beyers around 1997, never reribboned. They spend time on guitar amps occasionally too. When I was still trying to deal with SDC's, I frequently had them very much off axis shooting across the top of the cymbals and out into the room to try and tame them, never very good. I've been fighting an ancient remix with my old KM140's as OH recently, having to do lots of dynamic equalizer tricks to make the cymbals sit down and shut up in the mix. I'll use a condenser OH only after the drummer proves to be appropriately light touch on the cymbals. I can't imagine SPL killing a ribbon as OH. I recently for the first time had the pressure hole in the kick drum causing plosives in the M160 4 feet above it, perfectly positioned for a little air blast. Serious outlier there. There are a number of people I've heard comment about certain ribbons not being meant to face perfectly downwards parallel to the floor, like RCA 44's and 77's, opinion being they always sound better with some angle on them. I haven't pursued evidence of that.
|
|
|
Post by sean on Nov 25, 2022 15:02:48 GMT -6
I usually have M160/M130 in MS in my 7'6" room. I have 3 stereo Samar options, vintage RCA's, Fatheads, and the Beyers are just usually the thing that works best. I bought my Beyers around 1997, never reribboned. They spend time on guitar amps occasionally too. When I was still trying to deal with SDC's, I frequently had them very much off axis shooting across the top of the cymbals and out into the room to try and tame them, never very good. I've been fighting an ancient remix with my old KM140's as OH recently, having to do lots of dynamic equalizer tricks to make the cymbals sit down and shut up in the mix. I'll use a condenser OH only after the drummer proves to be appropriately light touch on the cymbals. I can't imagine SPL killing a ribbon as OH. I recently for the first time had the pressure hole in the kick drum causing plosives in the M160 4 feet above it, perfectly positioned for a little air blast. Serious outlier there. There are a number of people I've heard comment about certain ribbons not being meant to face perfectly downwards parallel to the floor, like RCA 44's and 77's, opinion being they always sound better with some angle on them. I haven't pursued evidence of that. Do you the the M/S set up overhead or in front of the kit?
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Nov 25, 2022 15:05:43 GMT -6
I usually have M160/M130 in MS Do you the the M/S set up overhead or in front of the kit? OH. Sometimes I also put a stereo Samar set out in front of the drums.
|
|
|
Post by bchurch on Nov 25, 2022 15:09:08 GMT -6
I say this as a self-professed basher, you'll do better with room mics than spaced / x-y OH's. Cymbals are just like any other large vibrating thing - you want to get enough distance that the thing that's vibrating can oscillate through its fundamental a couple of times to really "capture it". Yes, get the overheads in there for sizzle, but if I had the choice between ONLY a pair of overheads OR room mics 12' away for a drummer going down to pound town? It's gonna be B.
And +1 to using ribbons. Really takes the sharp edges off.
Preamp choice is another serious consideration - just as much as the mics themselves. I love my AML 1081 clones for drums - especially if it's me wailing away in margaritaville.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Nov 25, 2022 15:54:53 GMT -6
It's good to remember the tales of producers taking away drummers cymbals, or putting giant stripes of gaffe tape all over them.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 25, 2022 16:11:22 GMT -6
M160 are perfect. They have high end unlike most ribbons but a very specific sound.
A sturdier option is modern, high headroom sdcs. SDCs maintain the response better off axis than LDCs. I’d recommend Beyerdynamic MC930, Shure KSM 137, and maybe Austrian Audio CC8. Just de-ess your overheads and lower a high shelf. You’ll have to crank a high shelf anyway with most ribbons.
|
|
beyer160
Full Member
On Location
Posts: 43
|
Post by beyer160 on Nov 25, 2022 16:11:54 GMT -6
As you might have gathered by glancing to the left, I am a fan of the M160. Being one of the few non-fig 8 ribbon mics, I think they'd be great for your application. However, if you're concerned about drummers knocking them over in a confined space I'd think twice. 160s are reasonably hardy as ribbons go, but I wouldn't want to drop one- they're not Shures, after all.
What mics are you using now?
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Nov 25, 2022 18:15:09 GMT -6
You’ll have to crank a high shelf anyway with most ribbons. I've never added treble to a ribbon OH or drum room mic, FWIW. I am a fan of the M160. if you're concerned about drummers knocking them over in a confined space I'd think twice.g now? I had a drummer on a bouncy stage knock an M160 stand over. No damage. I expected it to be shot. The piston types are more rigid in some ways and these are short, not longer types with more potential play.
|
|
|
Post by theglow on Nov 25, 2022 18:30:26 GMT -6
I use M160s as overheads 90% of the time. They just work, and are extremely robust… all kinds of drops and stick hits and phantom power oopsies and no issues in the past decade I’ve used them.
I think it’s worth mentioning that cymbal harshness is generally in the 2.5-4khz area, and M160s actually have a presence boost there, so you may have better results with a mic that has a bit of a dip there like a Neumann U89 (or possibly an MD441 set to flat), although I’m basing that on frequency response charts; never used them for that purpose.
I’m generally fine using a bit of multiband compression or Soothe2 on that area when I’m using the M160s.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 25, 2022 18:33:16 GMT -6
I use M160s as overheads 90% of the time. They just work, and are extremely robust… all kinds of drops and stick hits and phantom power oopsies and no issues in the past decade I’ve used them. I think it’s worth mentioning that cymbal harshness is generally in the 2.5-4khz area, and M160s actually have a presence boost there, so you may have better results with a mic that has a bit of a dip there like a Neumann U89 (or possibly an MD441 set to flat), although I’m basing that on frequency response charts; never used them for that purpose. I’m generally fine using a bit of multiband compression or Soothe2 on that area when I’m using the M160s. Just de-ess them at 2-4khz for the cymbal crashes. I do that all the time.
|
|
|
Post by RealNoob on Nov 25, 2022 21:34:33 GMT -6
Two AL95 ribbons would sound great. They aren't wooly or dull like some ribbons. The top sounds very natural, just a tad warm/smooth. If I had 2, I'd use them on OH myself. I currently use Beesneez LuLu FETs. They two are very natural. I can't recall editing harshness out of them either.
Also, I'd put my XY or configure my split over the snare, rather than over the toms/cymbals. I find I get a better kit picture and am never lacking cymbals. It does make the OH much more useable in the overall tone, than just for cymbals sounds.
|
|
|
Post by svart on Nov 25, 2022 22:04:29 GMT -6
Never had any issue with oktava mk012s. The pad gets screwed in between the capsule and the amp. I'm a fan of the MK-012 but they might be a little too present for a cymbal basher. Not at all. I've used them for all kinds of music and styles and never had any issue.
|
|
|
Post by anders on Nov 26, 2022 2:38:52 GMT -6
Abba producer Michael Tretow, who didn't like cymbals, moved the overheads below the kit (underheads?). Maybe something to try out.
Also there are ribbons that are darker than the M160. I have a soft spot for the NoHypeAudio LRM-V
|
|