|
Post by EmRR on Mar 10, 2020 15:25:01 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by bricejchandler on Mar 11, 2020 14:29:45 GMT -6
I'm not sure how you guys are doing over there but the situation is catastrophic over here in the EU. I'm working in France right now and the government has banned gatherings of 1000 people or more so all my friends working in the live industry are hit really hard. All my upcoming gigs have been canceled , everything for the next 3 months canceled ! Trying to stay positive but man it's gonna be tough, was thinking about coming back stateside a bit but then I don't want to contaminate my family, I don't have the virus but living in Paris, with the amount of people I see everyday, I'm gonna err on the side of caution.
|
|
|
Post by johneppstein on Mar 11, 2020 14:55:44 GMT -6
I'm not sure how you guys are doing over there but the situation is catastrophic over here in the EU. I'm working in France right now and the government has banned gatherings of 1000 people or more so all my friends working in the live industry are hit really hard. All my upcoming gigs have been canceled , everything for the next 3 months canceled ! Trying to stay positive but man it's gonna be tough, was thinking about coming back stateside a bit but then I don't want to contaminate my family, I don't have the virus but living in Paris, with the amount of people I see everyday, I'm gonna err on the side of caution. I dunno. My guess is that you're probably safer over there - at least governments in Europe are taking it seriously and making testing available to all that need it - unlike here where what passes for a federal government is trying to sweep the whole thing under the rug and are actually doing everything possible to block the availability of testing for the majority of the population, while cutting funding to the bone for all the health related agencies.
And the a-holes here dumped the first batch right in the town I live in and didn't tell anyone about it for several days, while not taking adequate precautions to prevent spread to the general populace. And today (or was it yesterday?) they're docking an infected cruise ship right in the densely populated city of Oakland, a relatively short distance away. One would almost suspect that they're intentionally trying to infect California. Now why would they want to do that?
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Mar 11, 2020 15:06:09 GMT -6
johneppstein may be right, and at least there you are further along the curve. If you come over here you're just going back to an earlier part of the curve. The same measures you're seeing there are coming here quickly. All my live event work for the spring has been canceled, something like 35 full booking days.
|
|
|
Post by bricejchandler on Mar 11, 2020 15:08:34 GMT -6
I'm not sure how you guys are doing over there but the situation is catastrophic over here in the EU. I'm working in France right now and the government has banned gatherings of 1000 people or more so all my friends working in the live industry are hit really hard. All my upcoming gigs have been canceled , everything for the next 3 months canceled ! Trying to stay positive but man it's gonna be tough, was thinking about coming back stateside a bit but then I don't want to contaminate my family, I don't have the virus but living in Paris, with the amount of people I see everyday, I'm gonna err on the side of caution. I dunno. My guess is that you're probably safer over there - at least governments in Europe are taking it seriously and making testing available to all that need it - unlike here where what passes for a federal government is trying to sweep the whole thing under the rug and are actually doing everything possible to block the availability of testing for the majority of the population, while cutting funding to the bone for all the health related agencies.
And the a-holes here dumped the first batch right in the town I live in and didn't tell anyone about it for several days, while not taking adequate precautions to prevent spread to the general populace. And today (or was it yesterday?) they're docking an infected cruise ship right in the densely populated city of Oakland, a relatively short distance away. One would almost suspect that they're intentionally trying to infect California. Now why would they want to do that?
Yeah I was thinking of coming over not so much to escape Europe but to spend time with my family since I'm not gonna be working much. France is not a perfect but the healthcare system here is amazing.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on Mar 11, 2020 15:19:24 GMT -6
I'm not sure how you guys are doing over there but the situation is catastrophic over here in the EU. I'm working in France right now and the government has banned gatherings of 1000 people or more so all my friends working in the live industry are hit really hard. All my upcoming gigs have been canceled , everything for the next 3 months canceled ! Trying to stay positive but man it's gonna be tough, was thinking about coming back stateside a bit but then I don't want to contaminate my family, I don't have the virus but living in Paris, with the amount of people I see everyday, I'm gonna err on the side of caution. I dunno. My guess is that you're probably safer over there - at least governments in Europe are taking it seriously and making testing available to all that need it - unlike here where what passes for a federal government is trying to sweep the whole thing under the rug and are actually doing everything possible to block the availability of testing for the majority of the population, while cutting funding to the bone for all the health related agencies.
And the a-holes here dumped the first batch right in the town I live in and didn't tell anyone about it for several days, while not taking adequate precautions to prevent spread to the general populace. And today (or was it yesterday?) they're docking an infected cruise ship right in the densely populated city of Oakland, a relatively short distance away. One would almost suspect that they're intentionally trying to infect California. Now why would they want to do that?
I work in healthcare, specifically critical care for adults, pediatrics and neonates. Let me assure you that the precautions being taken are above and beyond what is needed. Measles, Chicken Pox, TB, Bacterial Meningitis...all things that are way worse than COVID, yet handled with much less precautions. Even influenza is in many cases worse. What we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria. You're right that most people are not being tested, that's due to availability of the test kits and also due to the fact that most people experience mild symptoms and simply need to self quarantine for a time and then they're fine. It's part of triage for any disaster. The overly cautious precautions that we're required to take has, in fact, caused a severe shortage of healthcare workers as we keep getting remanded to self quarantine for getting exposed. At this rate we'll be critically short of staff in a very short time. To put the whole thing in perspective, this current flu season there were, I believe, 26 million people infected, and 25,000 deaths. We (as a society) didn't act this way with H1N1 (which was waaaayy worse), Swine Flu, Bird Flu, SARS etc.
|
|
|
Post by ragan on Mar 11, 2020 15:25:13 GMT -6
I dunno. My guess is that you're probably safer over there - at least governments in Europe are taking it seriously and making testing available to all that need it - unlike here where what passes for a federal government is trying to sweep the whole thing under the rug and are actually doing everything possible to block the availability of testing for the majority of the population, while cutting funding to the bone for all the health related agencies.
And the a-holes here dumped the first batch right in the town I live in and didn't tell anyone about it for several days, while not taking adequate precautions to prevent spread to the general populace. And today (or was it yesterday?) they're docking an infected cruise ship right in the densely populated city of Oakland, a relatively short distance away. One would almost suspect that they're intentionally trying to infect California. Now why would they want to do that?
I work in healthcare, specifically critical care for adults, pediatrics and neonates. Let me assure you that the precautions being taken are above and beyond what is needed. Measles, Chicken Pox, TB, Bacterial Meningitis...all things that are way worse than COVID, yet handled with much less precautions. Even influenza is in many cases worse. What we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria. You're right that most people are not being tested, that's due to availability of the test kits and also due to the fact that most people experience mild symptoms and simply need to self quarantine for a time and then they're fine. It's part of triage for any disaster. The overly cautious precautions that we're required to take has, in fact, caused a severe shortage of healthcare workers as we keep getting remanded to self quarantine for getting exposed. At this rate we'll be critically short of staff in a very short time. To put the whole thing in perspective, this current flu season there were, I believe, 26 million people infected, and 25,000 deaths. We (as a society) didn't act this way with H1N1 (which was waaaayy worse), Swine Flu, Bird Flu, SARS etc. So the epidemiologists are just being paranoid and crazy and going rogue from their data, that's the claim here?
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Mar 11, 2020 15:37:03 GMT -6
I work in healthcare, specifically critical care for adults, pediatrics and neonates. Let me assure you that the precautions being taken are above and beyond what is needed. Measles, Chicken Pox, TB, Bacterial Meningitis...all things that are way worse than COVID, yet handled with much less precautions. Even influenza is in many cases worse. What we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria. You're right that most people are not being tested, that's due to availability of the test kits and also due to the fact that most people experience mild symptoms and simply need to self quarantine for a time and then they're fine. It's part of triage for any disaster. The overly cautious precautions that we're required to take has, in fact, caused a severe shortage of healthcare workers as we keep getting remanded to self quarantine for getting exposed. At this rate we'll be critically short of staff in a very short time. To put the whole thing in perspective, this current flu season there were, I believe, 26 million people infected, and 25,000 deaths. We (as a society) didn't act this way with H1N1 (which was waaaayy worse), Swine Flu, Bird Flu, SARS etc. So the epidemiologists are just being paranoid and crazy and going rogue from their data, that's the claim here? Yeah, not buying it. You don't see exponential growth until it's past critical mass, and that looks to be coming soon if not already past. These reports out of the bad parts of Italy (not huge numbers), if to be believed, suggest pure triage with the healthcare system totally overwhelmed. Sure, give it 2 months, and it'll all be back to normal once the living have recovered from the wave. I can't say I have ever known anyone to die form the flu, and with the mortality estimate ranges on this, we will ALL know SOMEONE who dies in this. I know a hell of a lot of people over 70 and 80. I'm not too concerned for my own health, yet am glad the wife and I work from home and my studio location. We can electively self isolate very easily, and plan to be ready to do so. I do see many of your points, but isn't overly cautious better than oblivious? Oblivious is what I'm seeing a lot of amongst acquaintances.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on Mar 11, 2020 16:49:51 GMT -6
I work in healthcare, specifically critical care for adults, pediatrics and neonates. Let me assure you that the precautions being taken are above and beyond what is needed. Measles, Chicken Pox, TB, Bacterial Meningitis...all things that are way worse than COVID, yet handled with much less precautions. Even influenza is in many cases worse. What we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria. You're right that most people are not being tested, that's due to availability of the test kits and also due to the fact that most people experience mild symptoms and simply need to self quarantine for a time and then they're fine. It's part of triage for any disaster. The overly cautious precautions that we're required to take has, in fact, caused a severe shortage of healthcare workers as we keep getting remanded to self quarantine for getting exposed. At this rate we'll be critically short of staff in a very short time. To put the whole thing in perspective, this current flu season there were, I believe, 26 million people infected, and 25,000 deaths. We (as a society) didn't act this way with H1N1 (which was waaaayy worse), Swine Flu, Bird Flu, SARS etc. So the epidemiologists are just being paranoid and crazy and going rogue from their data, that's the claim here? Not at all, don't know how you even inferred that. But the CDC reports are changing by the day, sometime by the hour. They won't have clear data sets for possibly another 18 months so there's a lot that's not yet known. Yes, this is a highly infectious disease. But simply not as catastrophic as the media and general public are making it out to be. The at risk population is manly elderly, and people who are already immune compromised. The same population that is at risk for pneumonia, influenza, CRE, VRE, MRSA, sepsis and a host of other diseases that will easily kill the older population. As testing becomes more wide spread you'll see more and more confirmed cases, more testing = more cases. Plus its already in the community so you'll continue to see true person-person transmission reflected in the stats as well. That paints a very bleak picture, but if you step back from it all and compare it what we (as healthcare workers) deal with every single day, it all of sudden doesn't look scary at all. BTW, here's what the epidemiologists at the CDC are saying right now: www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-in-us.htmlThose numbers will vary somewhat, for reasons I already covered.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on Mar 11, 2020 16:56:39 GMT -6
So the epidemiologists are just being paranoid and crazy and going rogue from their data, that's the claim here? Yeah, not buying it. You don't see exponential growth until it's past critical mass, and that looks to be coming soon if not already past. These reports out of the bad parts of Italy (not huge numbers), if to be believed, suggest pure triage with the healthcare system totally overwhelmed. Sure, give it 2 months, and it'll all be back to normal once the living have recovered from the wave. I can't say I have ever known anyone to die form the flu, and with the mortality estimate ranges on this, we will ALL know SOMEONE who dies in this. I know a hell of a lot of people over 70 and 80. I'm not too concerned for my own health, yet am glad the wife and I work from home and my studio location. We can electively self isolate very easily, and plan to be ready to do so. I do see many of your points, but isn't overly cautious better than oblivious? Oblivious is what I'm seeing a lot of amongst acquaintances. Yes better cautious than not, but cautious to the point of crippling the healthcare system results in more deaths, not fewer. There are actually some prelim reports that the mortality rate may now be coming down. That may just be a statistical anomaly as they confirm more cases, but also because we have a better handle on how to treat it. I've seen people die from influenza quite often. It's very common. But since no one seems to believe me, here ya go: www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/index.htmlBetween 12,000-60,000 influenza deaths each year, in the US alone, since 2010.
|
|
|
Post by ragan on Mar 11, 2020 17:16:53 GMT -6
So the epidemiologists are just being paranoid and crazy and going rogue from their data, that's the claim here? Not at all, don't know how you even inferred that. But the CDC reports are changing by the day, sometime by the hour. They won't have clear data sets for possibly another 18 months so there's a lot that's not yet known. Yes, this is a highly infectious disease. But simply not as catastrophic as the media and general public are making it out to be. The at risk population is manly elderly, and people who are already immune compromised. The same population that is at risk for pneumonia, influenza, CRE, VRE, MRSA, sepsis and a host of other diseases that will easily kill the older population. As testing becomes more wide spread you'll see more and more confirmed cases, more testing = more cases. Plus its already in the community so you'll continue to see true person-person transmission reflected in the stats as well. That paints a very bleak picture, but if you step back from it all and compare it what we (as healthcare workers) deal with every single day, it all of sudden doesn't look scary at all. BTW, here's what the epidemiologists at the CDC are saying right now: www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-in-us.htmlThose numbers will vary somewhat, for reasons I already covered. I guess I inferred it based on statements like "what we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria" and your minimization of it by saying well, influenza is just as bad and we're much more cavalier about measles, chicken pox, etc and your assertion that the mandated procedural response will have us running out of medical staff very soon. I am not an epidemiologist (obviously) so I wouldn't claim to have any real expertise here. But what I'm reading from epidemiologists does not suggest we're engaged in some purely hysterical response. It's a new virus that's highly infectious and it has a significant mortality rate (I don't care that I myself am not in one of the most vulnerable demographics). We have neither herd immunity nor a vaccine. Doesn't mean the sky is falling but it seems to me that it does mean it's something to be taken seriously and that sluggish responses and active disinformation from the highest ranks like we've seen in the US will make it worse than it would have been else-wise. I am curious what your job in medicine is? I mean that absolutely non-argumentatively. You're expressing your views based on some authority (which is totally valid) and I'd just like to know more about where it's coming from. I mean hell, maybe I'm talking to an epidemiologist right now.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on Mar 11, 2020 18:08:52 GMT -6
Not at all, don't know how you even inferred that. But the CDC reports are changing by the day, sometime by the hour. They won't have clear data sets for possibly another 18 months so there's a lot that's not yet known. Yes, this is a highly infectious disease. But simply not as catastrophic as the media and general public are making it out to be. The at risk population is manly elderly, and people who are already immune compromised. The same population that is at risk for pneumonia, influenza, CRE, VRE, MRSA, sepsis and a host of other diseases that will easily kill the older population. As testing becomes more wide spread you'll see more and more confirmed cases, more testing = more cases. Plus its already in the community so you'll continue to see true person-person transmission reflected in the stats as well. That paints a very bleak picture, but if you step back from it all and compare it what we (as healthcare workers) deal with every single day, it all of sudden doesn't look scary at all. BTW, here's what the epidemiologists at the CDC are saying right now: www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-in-us.htmlThose numbers will vary somewhat, for reasons I already covered. I guess I inferred it based on statements like "what we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria" and your minimization of it by saying well, influenza is just as bad and we're much more cavalier about measles, chicken pox, etc and your assertion that the mandated procedural response will have us running out of medical staff very soon. I am not an epidemiologist (obviously) so I wouldn't claim to have any real expertise here. But what I'm reading from epidemiologists does not suggest we're engaged in some purely hysterical response. It's a new virus that's highly infectious and it has a significant mortality rate (I don't care that I myself am not in one of the most vulnerable demographics). We have neither herd immunity nor a vaccine. Doesn't mean the sky is falling but it seems to me that it does mean it's something to be taken seriously and that sluggish responses and active disinformation from the highest ranks like we've seen in the US will make it worse than it would have been else-wise. I am curious what your job in medicine is? I mean that absolutely non-argumentatively. You're expressing your views based on some authority (which is totally valid) and I'd just like to know more about where it's coming from. I mean hell, maybe I'm talking to an epidemiologist right now. Fair enough, I can see how some of my comments are somewhat vague and can be interpreted differently then I meant. I'm speaking out of frustration and am more than a little jadded so I probably wasn't specific enough and probably came off wrong. By "hysteria" I meant more that the public reaction, media reporting, hording of toilet paper, shortage of hospital masks (both n95 rated and normal surgical masks) due to theft and supply shortages, and even cancelling events like SXSW is just over kill. By daughter wasn't allowed to high-five her teammates at her volleyball tournament...but they're all touching the same ball...so...yeah...measures like that do nothing. The response in the healthcare field has been overzealous. Up until, literally hours ago, we were required to undergo isolation measure that until now have only been used for Ebola. We're running out of negative pressure rooms because the CDC is recommending Airborne Precautions, but best guess at this point is that its spread through Aerosolized Droplets. If we are exposed to the virus (and many of us have been) its mandatory 14 day self-quarantine. We're running out of critical care hospital staff because of it. The mortality rate seems to be coming down, not growing. Its was reported to be about 2.5% in China, but any numbers coming from China are suspect for a variety of reasons and not necessarily representative of the virus as a whole. The New England Journal of Medicine estimates the mortality at around 1.4%. Keeping in mind that in many countries, like the US, only the sickest people are even tested for the virus and the actual mortality rate is very likely much lower than that. As to my profession, I'm a respiratory therapist. I'm a tier one healthcare worker, meaning I'm first in line to be exposed to COVID and to treat those with COVID in the Hospital setting. I work in Critical Care. I'm one of the few in my department cross trained in all areas, I work in CICU, ICU, NICU, PICU etc. I've worked in level one trauma centers, nationally recognized medical centers and small community hospitals. Most all of my patients are fighting for their lives. I've cared for countless people suffering from horrible diseases. I've watched more people die than I can count. I've done CPR more times than I can count. When someone is on life support, I'm there managing the ventilator. In fact I'm there for every Code Blue emergency in the hospital. I'm relied upon by Dr's to educate them to Pulmonary Disease processes and to help direct the care of critically ill people. Thats not say that I know everything, I certainly dont. And critical care medicine is a team sport, we all help and rely on each other. So, I'm not an epidemiologist either, but I do get briefings directly from our Infectious Disease MD's. A lot of the precautions taken were great, and needed. Earlier screening of people traveling from Asia would have been great. Being concerned is well justified. But the general response, and fear, I see in the community, and in some areas the Hospital, is not justified. That's my experience. Everyone is welcome to their own opinion. And I apologize if I come off argumentative, it's not my intention at all.
|
|
|
Post by ragan on Mar 11, 2020 18:20:43 GMT -6
I guess I inferred it based on statements like "what we're experiencing right now is nothing short of hysteria" and your minimization of it by saying well, influenza is just as bad and we're much more cavalier about measles, chicken pox, etc and your assertion that the mandated procedural response will have us running out of medical staff very soon. I am not an epidemiologist (obviously) so I wouldn't claim to have any real expertise here. But what I'm reading from epidemiologists does not suggest we're engaged in some purely hysterical response. It's a new virus that's highly infectious and it has a significant mortality rate (I don't care that I myself am not in one of the most vulnerable demographics). We have neither herd immunity nor a vaccine. Doesn't mean the sky is falling but it seems to me that it does mean it's something to be taken seriously and that sluggish responses and active disinformation from the highest ranks like we've seen in the US will make it worse than it would have been else-wise. I am curious what your job in medicine is? I mean that absolutely non-argumentatively. You're expressing your views based on some authority (which is totally valid) and I'd just like to know more about where it's coming from. I mean hell, maybe I'm talking to an epidemiologist right now. Fair enough, I can see how some of my comments are somewhat vague and can be interpreted differently then I meant. I'm speaking out of frustration and am more than a little jadded so I probably wasn't specific enough and probably came off wrong. By "hysteria" I meant more that the public reaction, media reporting, hording of toilet paper, shortage of hospital masks (both n95 rated and normal surgical masks) due to theft and supply shortages, and even cancelling events like SXSW is just over kill. By daughter wasn't allowed to high-five her teammates at her volleyball tournament...but they're all touching the same ball...so...yeah...measures like that do nothing. The response in the healthcare field has been overzealous. Up until, literally hours ago, we were required to undergo isolation measure that until now have only been used for Ebola. We're running out of negative pressure rooms because the CDC is recommending Airborne Precautions, but best guess at this point is that its spread through Aerosolized Droplets. If we are exposed to the virus (and many of us have been) its mandatory 14 day self-quarantine. We're running out of critical care hospital staff because of it. The mortality rate seems to be coming down, not growing. Its was reported to be about 2.5% in China, but any numbers coming from China are suspect for a variety of reasons and not necessarily representative of the virus as a whole. The New England Journal of Medicine estimates the mortality at around 1.4%. Keeping in mind that in many countries, like the US, only the sickest people are even tested for the virus and the actual mortality rate is very likely much lower than that. As to my profession, I'm a respiratory therapist. I'm a tier one healthcare worker, meaning I'm first in line to be exposed to COVID and to treat those with COVID in the Hospital setting. I work in Critical Care. I'm one of the few in my department cross trained in all areas, I work in CICU, ICU, NICU, PICU etc. I've worked in level one trauma centers, nationally recognized medical centers and small community hospitals. Most all of my patients are fighting for their lives. I've cared for countless people suffering from horrible diseases. I've watched more people die than I can count. I've done CPR more times than I can count. When someone is on life support, I'm there managing the ventilator. In fact I'm there for every Code Blue emergency in the hospital. I'm relied upon by Dr's to educate them to Pulmonary Disease processes and to help direct the care of critically ill people. Thats not say that I know everything, I certainly dont. And critical care medicine is a team sport, we all help and rely on each other. So, I'm not an epidemiologist either, but I do get briefings directly from our Infectious Disease MD's. A lot of the precautions taken were great, and needed. Earlier screening of people traveling from Asia would have been great. Being concerned is well justified. But the general response, and fear, I see in the community, and in some areas the Hospital, is not justified. That's my experience. Everyone is welcome to their own opinion. And I apologize if I come off argumentative, it's not my intention at all. That is great, thank you. It lets me place your views in light of your (significant) experience and knowledge and adjust my own understanding accordingly as I consider your take on things.
|
|
|
Post by Tbone81 on Mar 11, 2020 21:36:36 GMT -6
Fair enough, I can see how some of my comments are somewhat vague and can be interpreted differently then I meant. I'm speaking out of frustration and am more than a little jadded so I probably wasn't specific enough and probably came off wrong. By "hysteria" I meant more that the public reaction, media reporting, hording of toilet paper, shortage of hospital masks (both n95 rated and normal surgical masks) due to theft and supply shortages, and even cancelling events like SXSW is just over kill. By daughter wasn't allowed to high-five her teammates at her volleyball tournament...but they're all touching the same ball...so...yeah...measures like that do nothing. The response in the healthcare field has been overzealous. Up until, literally hours ago, we were required to undergo isolation measure that until now have only been used for Ebola. We're running out of negative pressure rooms because the CDC is recommending Airborne Precautions, but best guess at this point is that its spread through Aerosolized Droplets. If we are exposed to the virus (and many of us have been) its mandatory 14 day self-quarantine. We're running out of critical care hospital staff because of it. The mortality rate seems to be coming down, not growing. Its was reported to be about 2.5% in China, but any numbers coming from China are suspect for a variety of reasons and not necessarily representative of the virus as a whole. The New England Journal of Medicine estimates the mortality at around 1.4%. Keeping in mind that in many countries, like the US, only the sickest people are even tested for the virus and the actual mortality rate is very likely much lower than that. As to my profession, I'm a respiratory therapist. I'm a tier one healthcare worker, meaning I'm first in line to be exposed to COVID and to treat those with COVID in the Hospital setting. I work in Critical Care. I'm one of the few in my department cross trained in all areas, I work in CICU, ICU, NICU, PICU etc. I've worked in level one trauma centers, nationally recognized medical centers and small community hospitals. Most all of my patients are fighting for their lives. I've cared for countless people suffering from horrible diseases. I've watched more people die than I can count. I've done CPR more times than I can count. When someone is on life support, I'm there managing the ventilator. In fact I'm there for every Code Blue emergency in the hospital. I'm relied upon by Dr's to educate them to Pulmonary Disease processes and to help direct the care of critically ill people. Thats not say that I know everything, I certainly dont. And critical care medicine is a team sport, we all help and rely on each other. So, I'm not an epidemiologist either, but I do get briefings directly from our Infectious Disease MD's. A lot of the precautions taken were great, and needed. Earlier screening of people traveling from Asia would have been great. Being concerned is well justified. But the general response, and fear, I see in the community, and in some areas the Hospital, is not justified. That's my experience. Everyone is welcome to their own opinion. And I apologize if I come off argumentative, it's not my intention at all. That is great, thank you. It lets me place your views in light of your (significant) experience and knowledge and adjust my own understanding accordingly as I consider your take on things. Thank you for inquiring and for hearing me out. It says a lot that you take the time to understand where people are coming from before making a judgement for yourself.
Also, its one of the reasons I love RGO. Being able to challenge each other but still be respectful...its a lost art my friend.
|
|
|
Post by Blackdawg on Mar 11, 2020 22:30:39 GMT -6
The numbers just don't line up with the response people are having to this. Here are some:
|
|
|
Post by M57 on Mar 12, 2020 4:28:59 GMT -6
Lot's of info there. I found the link here if anyone is interested. I think the fact that it is so much more deadly for our elderly population, many of whom live in clusters, speaks to how important it is to try and contain it or at least slow it down. Hysteria is borne of lacking and/or misinformation. Knowledge transparency, and application of good practice by governments world-wide are the keys.
|
|
|
Post by ragan on Mar 12, 2020 5:52:57 GMT -6
Some of those statistics, while true, are sort of irrelevant and/or miss the point in my view.
Of course covid 19 gets more mentions in the media. It’s new and it’s happening right now. It’s a rapidly changing situation with immediate global implications. There is going to be more reporting on it than something long studied and static like pneumonia. And figures like total deaths somewhat miss the point. You don’t need epidemiologists to study things and run data models to tell you what *has* happened. You need them to tell you what the probability of various *future* outcomes is so you can decide what to do about it.
Seems to me there are parallel truths. The covid 19 outbreak is serious and worth responding to AND some people are being crazy about it. Neither truth negates the other.
|
|
|
Post by jcoutu1 on Mar 12, 2020 13:44:37 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by rowmat on Mar 12, 2020 15:02:29 GMT -6
The issue is that 10% - 15% will require ICU hospitalization. Around 5% will require mechanical respiration. The relatively mild symptoms many have is actually something to be extremely concerned about. Those with little or no symptoms are very efficient at silently spreading the virus around infecting those who are far more vulnerable to becoming extremely ill. Few understand the exponential function. Expect to see massive spikes in infection rates in the US, UK, Australia etc over the next 7 - 14 days. The other issue is permanent lung damage which is becoming apparent in the survivors. This is NOT just another 'Flu'. The only option is to avoid gatherings, enclosed spaces and maintain safe distances from others. If not the infection rate will overwhelm the hospital system and the death toll will likely exceed 10% which is where Northern Italy is heading now. Patients over 60 are not being treated in Northern Italy and are being left to die.
See attached graph.
Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by Darren Boling on Mar 13, 2020 0:31:42 GMT -6
Thanks for all the info guys. The tour I'm currently on was just postponed, found out right before we went on stage for what became our last show tonite in Chicago. To be honest it was starting to become obvious it was going to happen after all the festival cancellations and seeing the crowd numbers become less than what the ticket sales were.
|
|
|
Post by the other mark williams on Mar 15, 2020 4:00:44 GMT -6
We just cancelled/postponed an upcoming Dylan cover gig. It was scheduled for two weeks from now at Cat's Cradle in Carrboro, NC. It was going to be a killer show. I hope we can do it a few months later.
|
|
|
Post by gwlee7 on Mar 15, 2020 18:51:18 GMT -6
We just cancelled/postponed an upcoming Dylan cover gig. It was scheduled for two weeks from now at Cat's Cradle in Carrboro, NC. It was going to be a killer show. I hope we can do it a few months later. A gabillion years ago, in a galaxy far, far, away, I played a gig at The Cave in Chapel Hill. Like 1984 or 85. The Cat’s Cradle was around way back then too. I hope things get back normal soon.
|
|
|
Post by the other mark williams on Mar 15, 2020 19:05:24 GMT -6
We just cancelled/postponed an upcoming Dylan cover gig. It was scheduled for two weeks from now at Cat's Cradle in Carrboro, NC. It was going to be a killer show. I hope we can do it a few months later. A gabillion years ago, in a galaxy far, far, away, I played a gig at The Cave in Chapel Hill. Like 1984 or 85. The Cat’s Cradle was around way back then too. I hope things get back normal soon. Ohhhhh yeah - I know The Cave. R.E.M. showed up and did an unannounced gig there when they were touring for Monster and played the Dean Dome, I think. And yeah, Frank has had Cat's Cradle going for a good long while now. They've subsumed a few other places and have expanded a lot. Good scene. What was/is your band, gwlee7 ?
|
|
|
Post by gwlee7 on Mar 15, 2020 20:17:28 GMT -6
A gabillion years ago, in a galaxy far, far, away, I played a gig at The Cave in Chapel Hill. Like 1984 or 85. The Cat’s Cradle was around way back then too. I hope things get back normal soon. Ohhhhh yeah - I know The Cave. R.E.M. showed up and did an unannounced gig there when they were touring for Monster and played the Dean Dome, I think. And yeah, Frank has had Cat's Cradle going for a good long while now. They've subsumed a few other places and have expanded a lot. Good scene. What was/is your band, gwlee7 ? That little duo I played with at the Cave was called Nowhere Fast. It was me and the guy I grew up learning how to play the guitar with. I have been in a lot of other bands over the years that have all fizzled out due to not being willing to starve to death. My biggest success is being able to say I played in a band out of Greenville NC in the late 80s and early 90s called Old Habits that used to out draw Hootie and the Blowfish when first they started coming around town. I wonder whatever became of those guys. 🤔🤣. Chapel Hill is a great place. I live in Dallas now and play and record mostly for fun. I am appreciative of all the time that those of you who still fight the good fight take up with me.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 17, 2020 16:39:56 GMT -6
i honestly think corona virus is a bullsh*t (excuse my french) but people are panicking too much. seemed like an overhyped flu. even if i get it, i could care less, im sure id recover. now if i was was 60-80s, it maybe slight concerning.
|
|
|
Post by EmRR on Mar 17, 2020 21:06:09 GMT -6
i honestly think corona virus is a bullsh*t (excuse my french) but people are panicking too much. seemed like an overhyped flu. even if i get it, i could care less, im sure id recover. now if i was was 60-80s, it maybe slight concerning. You should then look at the impact graphs in the projection studies. Several linked in the other thread.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 18, 2020 0:37:20 GMT -6
i honestly think corona virus is a bullsh*t (excuse my french) but people are panicking too much. seemed like an overhyped flu. even if i get it, i could care less, im sure id recover. now if i was was 60-80s, it maybe slight concerning. You should then look at the impact graphs in the projection studies. Several linked in the other thread. i have, the 90% death toll is elderly, not saying it cant happen to young. iits too late to be stopped, its gona spread. why fear it cause something we dont have no control over. people are absolutely freaking out and i seen more people die of other diseases.
|
|
|
Post by rowmat on Mar 18, 2020 4:24:47 GMT -6
You should then look at the impact graphs in the projection studies. Several linked in the other thread. i have, the 90% death toll is elderly, not saying it cant happen to young. iits too late to be stopped, its gona spread. why fear it cause something we dont have no control over. people are absolutely freaking out and i seen more people die of other diseases. Elderly death-toll is skewed above the 'norm' especially in Italy due to triage favoring younger critical patients who are given priority for the limited ICU beds and mechanical ventilators. Patients over 60 especially with comorbidities are often missing out on ICU beds altogether which in many cases means they don't survive where otherwise they may have. The lack of critical care equipment is forcing medical staff to make life and death decisions. This is going to be common everywhere due to the lack of ICU mechanical ventilators available to deal with a pandemic of this scale.
|
|